Why Is Car Insurance So Expensive in Michigan?

Michigan car insurance is typically expensive due to its no-fault insurance requirements, inflation, and high rates of uninsured drivers, fraud, and personal injury lawsuits.
Written by Jaya Anandjit
Edited by Jessica Barrett
Like most no-fault states,
car insurance can be expensive due to higher mandated
auto insurance
limits—including personal injury protection and property protection—plus inflation, and high rates of uninsured drivers, insurance fraud, and personal injury lawsuits.

5 reasons why Michigan car insurance is expensive

According to a 2020 report from the
Insurance Information Institute
(III), Michigan is the third most expensive state for car insurance on average. With that said, there are a few factors that contribute to Michigan’s high auto insurance rates: 
  • Michigan’s no-fault car insurance requirements
  • High rates of uninsured drivers on Michigan roads
  • Michigan’s insurance fraud problem
  • High rates of personal injury lawsuits in Michigan
  • Inflation and expenses in the auto insurance industry
Let’s go over each factor to unpack why your Michigan car insurance rates may fall on the higher side. 

Coverage requirements: Michigan is a no-fault state

Michigan is among other
no-fault states
on the III’s list of the most expensive states for auto insurance. No-fault state drivers typically face higher insurance rates due to increased mandated coverage types and higher liability coverage limits. 
For example: Idaho—an at-fault or tort state—is one of the cheapest states for car insurance, with 25/50/15 liability limits mandated by state law. On the other hand, Michigan’s no-fault insurance system requires 50/100/10 liability insurance, PIP coverage, PPI coverage, and 50/100 residual liability insurance.
Michigan car insurance requirements1
Michigan’s higher liability limits alongside PIP, PPI, and residual liability insurance provide great protection for the average Michigan driver, but these added benefits typically incur high insurance premiums. 
Michigan car insurance companies use several rating factors to determine rates for each driver. Your age, driving record, claims history, specific Michigan ZIP code, vehicle type, and credit score can impact your premiums.

High rates of uninsured drivers in Michigan

A 2019 report from the III found that Michigan has the second-highest percentage of uninsured motorists. 
With just over 25% of uninsured drivers in Michigan, car insurance companies face a higher risk of accidents involving a driver without coverage, and a major income loss from a lack of paying policyholders. For these reasons, Michigan car insurance policies typically incur higher premiums.

Michigan’s insurance fraud problem

While Michigan’s legislature strictly prohibits insurance fraud, the state experiences a large amount of fraudulent no-fault insurance claims. 
In fact, Michigan’s
2023 Fraud Investigation Unit Annual Report
shows that 21% of bodily injury claims and 18% of personal injury protection claims appear to be fraud or build-up. Additionally, many drivers provide false personal information to receive lower car insurance rates based on their ZIP code location and overall vehicle mileage. To compensate for the financial loss posed by auto claim fraud, insurers charge higher premiums in Michigan. 
Why is fraud so prevalent in the Great Lake State? 
Michigan insurance law requires all auto insurance providers to resolve claims within 30 days, so this may be a contributing factor in the high return of fraudulent claims.

High rates of personal injury lawsuits in Michigan

Although Michigan’s no-fault insurance laws are meant to limit the amount of personal injury lawsuits between drivers after an accident, the state faces a different problem: drivers suing their insurance provider for no-fault insurance claims. 
Yearly, Michigan insurance providers face multiple lawsuits from drivers and medical providers over unpaid claims, so insurers increase rates to make up for financial losses.

The auto industry & inflation

Michigan car insurance rates may be generally higher than the rest of the country’s, but the Great Lake State doesn’t stand alone when it comes to the pressure of inflation. 
Rising vehicle values, higher repair costs, steep medical expenses, and larger insurance claims all contribute to inflated car insurance rates across the country. In fact, the
Bureau of Labor Statistics
finds that car insurance rates increase by an average of 18.9% every year, and rates have gone up substantially since 2021 in response to the pandemic.

Michigan car insurance costs

As of November 2023, Michigan auto insurance costs an average of $167 per month for state-minimum policies or $189 per month for full coverage. Those averages come out to $1,999 per year for minimum coverage or $2,272 annually for full coverage on average. 
Michigan’s car insurance rates fall just above the current national average of $2,264 per year for full coverage. Here’s how Michigan’s auto insurance rates compare to a few other states: 
No-fault or at-fault regulations?
Average cost of full coverage
New York
North Dakota
National average
Methodology: Jerry conducted a nationwide survey, analyzing over 25 million car insurance quotes to confirm the average cost of car insurance per state. 
While Michigan car insurance rates are generally high, there are still a few ways to lower your premiums. First and foremost, comparing quotes from different providers can help you uncover the lowest potential rate for your driver profile. 
app screenshot
The Jerry app offers an easy coverage selection process and guides you through building your profile to ensure you take advantage of discounts you might be eligible for.
Download the app to view insurance quotes that are tailored to your personal profile.


Is Michigan the highest state for car insurance?

Michigan is not the most expensive state for car insurance, but it is among some of the most expensive. A 2020 report from the Insurance Information Institute (III) finds that Michigan is the third most expensive state for car insurance, following Louisiana and New York.

Did Michigan car insurance go up in 2023?

Yes, Michigan car insurance rates have increased in 2023. On average, Michigan car insurance rates are up by 31% since 2022, when the Michigan Catastrophic Claims Association (MCCA) implemented a rate hike.

Who has the cheapest car insurance in Michigan?

There isn’t a single insurance provider that consistently offers low rates to all drivers, but companies like Secura, GEICO, Farm Bureau, and Auto-Owners offer some of the cheapest premiums in Michigan.

What is the average monthly cost of car insurance in Michigan?

The average monthly cost of car insurance in Michigan is $167 for state-minimum policies or $189 for full coverage.

What coverage is required in Michigan?

Michigan requires $50,000 of bodily injury liability (BIL) per person, $100,000 of bodily injury liability (BIL), $10,000 of property damage liability (PDL) per accident per accident, $250,000 of personal injury protection (PIP) for medical coverage, $1,000,000 of property protection insurance (PPI) per accident, $50,000 of residual liability insurance per person, and $100,000 of residual liability insurance per accident. 

What is Michigan’s insurance reform?

In 2019, Michigan altered its insurance requirements and scrapped the mandatory unlimited PIP coverage requirement. Now, Michigan residents can lower their insurance premiums by opting to use their personal healthcare insurance for medical bills rather than purchasing unlimited personal injury protection

Easiest way to compare and buy car insurance

No long forms
No spam or unwanted phone calls
Quotes from top insurance companies
Find insurance savings