According to real quotes from Jerry drivers, the most expensive SUV to insure is none other than the performance forward, yet luxurious BMW X6 xDrive50i.
Because of their size and high-end finishes, SUVs tend to be more expensive to insure than your average sedan. But it can be hard to tell which SUVs are especially expensive to insure.
That’s why the car insurance broker app Jerry.ai used car insurance quotes from real customers to find the most expensive SUV to insure in the United States.
Just because these cars are more expensive than average to insure, doesn’t mean you can not find a good deal. In fact, drivers that switched policies with Jerry save an average of $879 a year on car insurance!
The Top 10 Most Expensive SUVs
Drivers that own the SUVs on this list save big on insurance when they switch carriers with Jerry.
See for yourself!
Volkswagen Tiguan SE
A spacious cabin, top-of-the-line safety features, and powerful onboard technology.
The Tiguan SE is a three-row, front-wheel drive SUV with LED lights, heated mirrors, and superior safety ratings for crash prevention.
It is considered a compact SUV, making it a popular choice for city dwellers. However, it has below-average fuel economy ratings and some drivers described the Tiguan’s engine as “weak.”
If you’re looking for a more affordable alternative, check out Toyota’s RAV4. It is a few inches shorter than the Tiguan and it only seats five people, but the RAV4 offers better fuel economy and gets higher ratings on safety features.
- Average annual premium before Jerry: $2,982
- Average annual premium after Jerry: $2,064
- Miles per gallon: City 23/ highway 29
- Car and Driver rating: n/a
- List price: $26,440 (2018)
Jeep Grand Cherokee Trailhawk
For the off-road enthusiast who appreciates a little luxury.
Jeeps are known for being the vehicle-of-choice for back-country adventures and the Trailhawk is no exception.
It comes standard with a V6 engine, but, notably, there’s an option to upgrade to a V8.
The interior of this SUV is pure luxury, with leather upholstery, mood lighting, and the Uconnect A/V system.
The Trailhawk doesn’t come cheap, so the Dodge Durango might be a good alternative if you want similar features at a more affordable price point.
You’ll have to upgrade to a V8 and AWD if you plan to drive through rough terrain, but otherwise the Durango offers similar on-board entertainment, storage, and towing capacity.
- Average annual premium before Jerry: $2,994
- Average annual premium after Jerry: $2,383
- Miles per gallon: City 18/ highway 24
- Car and Driver Rating: 8
- List price: $35,890 (2021)
Safe and affordable.
The Ford Explorer offers standard features for an SUV, including an on-board infotainment system and an upscale interior.
It is slightly more cramped than other SUVs and doesn’t handle winding roads as well as its competitors.
However, the Explorer is one of the most affordable SUVs and it comes with excellent safety ratings.
For a cheaper option, consider the Hyundai Santa Fe or the Buick Enclave. The Enclave seats up to eight people and has comparable safety ratings to the Ford Explorer.
The Santa Fe affords you a stronger engine plus the same seating capacity as the Explorer.
- Average annual premium before Jerry: $3,380
- Average annual premium after Jerry: $2,386
- Miles per gallon: City 18/ highway 24
- Car and Driver Rating: 7.5
- List price: $33,470 (2021)
Chevrolet Blazer V10
Smooth steering paired with a strong fuel economy.
The Blazer is a midsize SUV with an epic towing capacity and great safety ratings.
The body style of this Chevy is a bit more muscular than other SUVs and cargo space and headroom suffer as a result.
Drivers can choose to upgrade to a variety of high-end trim and technology options.
For a slightly less expensive substitute, check out the Ford Edge (more info below) to get comparable engine power and cabin capacity at a lower price.
- Average annual premium before Jerry: $4,170
- Average annual premium after Jerry: $2,832
- Miles per gallon: City 24/ highway 29
- Car and Driver rating: 6.5
- List price: $29,995 (2021)
Ford Edge SE
Plenty of cabin space and engine power.
With two rows instead of three, the Edge offers greater comfort in exchange for reduced capacity.
This SUV provides a stable ride over rough roads and good fuel economy, although the interior finishes are slightly less impressive than its competitors.
Consider the Chevrolet Equinox if you want to pay less for a similar SUV. The Equinox also has two rows, but you’ll enjoy greater power with three turbo-charged four-cylinder engines under the hood.
- Average annual premium before Jerry: $3,236
- Average annual premium after Jerry: $2,856
- Miles per gallon: City 21/ highway 28
- Car and Driver rating: 6.5
- List price: $32,495 (2021)
Hyundai Tucson Sport
A comfortable but a below-average fuel economy.
This Hyundai SUV can seat five and ranks well for reliability. It is thousands of dollars cheaper than its rivals while still offering comparable technology and features.
However, the Tucson Sport gets lackluster performance ratings and its cabin is smaller than most competitors.
For a cheaper option, look to the Honda HR-V. It’s roomy and has tons of great interior features, like rear seats that flip down to create more storage. The HR-V has slightly better fuel economy and best-in-class warranty—all for less than the Hyundai Tucson Sport.
- Average annual premium before Jerry: $3,840
- Average annual premium after Jerry: $3,012
- Miles per gallon: City 22/ highway 28
- Car and Driver rating: 8
- List price: $29,435 (2021)
Jeep Grand Cherokee SRT
The SRT-8 delivers daily performance and monstrous towing capacity.
The SRT-8 has a maximum tow capacity of 7,200 pounds.
However, the interior finishes are not on par with luxury SUVs and the fuel economy is laughable.
If you’d like an SUV that can tow similarly heavy loads for less money and with better fuel efficiency, then leave the Jeep Grand Cherokee behind and choose the Chevy Traverse.
You’ll be able to tow up to 5,000 pounds at that price point. That being said, if you really need the increased towing capacity, then you’ll have to pay more for a pricier luxury vehicle like a Land Rover or an Escalade.
- Average annual premium before Jerry: $4,216
- Average annual premium after Jerry: $3,536
- Miles per gallon: City 13/ highway 19
- Car and Driver rating: 8
- List price: $70,860 (2021)
Honda Pilot LX
A spacious interior, good fuel economy, and seating for eight.
The Pilot is a great three-row crossover SUV that is versatile and incredibly roomy.
Drivers will enjoy a smooth ride and great fuel economy with the Pilot LX, although some drivers report a lack of body control that can feel disconcerting.
The baseline Honda Pilot LX is pretty affordable, so you won’t find a ton of comparable options for less. However, look into the VW Tiguan (described at the beginning of this article) if you’re interested in a cheaper and smaller SUV with similar features.
- Average annual premium before Jerry: $4,150
- Average annual premium after Jerry: $3,792
- Miles per gallon: City 20/ highway 27
- Car and Driver rating: 7.5
- List price: $33,725 (2021)
BMW X6 xDrive50i
Smooth and confident handling backed by pure power.
Like other vehicles from BMW, the X6 is a sleek blend of luxury and performance.
The cabin includes fine materials like Merino leather, and buyers can choose between carbon-fiber, oak, or aluminum trim.
BMW calls it a SAV (sports-activity vehicle) and it offers lightning-fast acceleration and smart technology.
It’s not hard to find an SUV more affordable than the X6, but look to the Jeep Grand Cherokee SRT for something similar at a better price point. However, you won’t find the same power or luxury finishes in other models.
- Average annual premium before Jerry: $9,216
- Average annual premium after Jerry: $4,596
- Miles per gallon: City 16/ highway 22
- Car and Driver rating: 9
- List price: $66,045 (2021)
Factors that impact your car insurance rate
Insurance companies use a few key data points to calculate your car insurance rate.
Some are out of your control, like your location or your age. But you can control plenty of other factors, like your driving record and what kind of vehicle you purchase.
Larger vehicles are typically considered safer and can be cheaper to insure. A smaller vehicle is more likely to be crushed in an accident, so you can expect to pay a higher rate to protect a small car versus a bigger car.
The exception is for SUVs and luxury vehicles, where the large size might be neutralized by expensive repair costs.
Expensive cars mean higher insurance payments since the company will have to pay to repair or replace your vehicle if anything happens to it.
Luxury and sports vehicles come with pricey car insurance. As a result, you’ll find more affordable insurance rates if you drive a more popular car with everyday finishes and standard safety features.
Safe drivers get better insurance rates.
If you get a speeding ticket or cause an accident, your insurance company will immediately raise your rate because they’ll label you high-risk.
Sometimes, the rate increase will be substantial. So drive cautiously—and purchase an accident forgiveness policy if you’re concerned about the effect an accident could have on your premium.
Vehicle Safety Ratings & Features
If your vehicle comes with automatic restraints, airbags, and other safety features, you are less likely to be injured in an accident.
A vehicle with a high safety rating could potentially have a lower insurance premium. Note that newer vehicles tend to have better safety features than older ones, although there haven’t been any hugely dramatic changes to car safety features in the last ten years.
Insurance companies use your address to determine risk. Higher risk means higher premiums.
Urban drivers are typically estimated to be at higher risk for theft (more neighbors around) and accidents (because they commute on heavily trafficked roads).
Some states require more coverage than others—and you’ll pay an increased price for it.
It’s hard to argue with data—and studies show that younger drivers just aren’t as safe as older drivers. New drivers pay some of the highest insurance rates. After a few years of safe driving experience, however, you can expect to pay a more affordable rate.
Married drivers are seen as more financially stable. As a result, they pay slightly less for car insurance than single, divorced, or widowed drivers. Bundling car insurance with your partner is a smart way to reduce your premium.
In most states (except California, Hawaii, and Massachusetts) your credit score will affect your insurance rate.
Most companies charge a driver with poor credit much more for car insurance than a similar driver who has good credit. Statistics show that drivers with better credit scores tend to get into fewer accidents—which means the insurance company doesn’t have to pay out as much cash.
To find the best car insurance rate for your situation, use Jerry.ai. Enter in your details and receive quotes in just 45 seconds.
You may think you’re stuck with the most expensive SUV to insure, but Jerry can help you find a better rate! If you find a better policy, Jerry will even cancel your old policy on your behalf and then file the paperwork to switch over.
What is the cheapest used SUV to insure?
The Honda Pilot VP at $816 is the cheapest used SUV to insure. With plenty of interior space and practical finishes, the Pilot VP is a great choice for an SUV with generally affordable insurance rates.
Why are SUVs more expensive than standard cars?
SUVs are more expensive than standard cars because they are larger, for one. They also tend to incorporate better quality materials and luxury features, which also raises the numbers on their price tags.
Are SUVs the safest family vehicle?
Yes, SUVs are generally considered to be some of the safest vehicles on the road.
In an accident, the smaller vehicle tends to bear the brunt of the damage, and SUVs provide extra protection since they’re higher up off the ground.
SUVs are more vulnerable to wind and rollovers, but overall they are a very safe vehicle choice for families.
How do I find the cheapest insurance for my SUV?
Insurance rates depend on your specific vehicle as well as your personal driving record and location. Plus, every company has a unique formula for calculating risk and assigning you a premium.
SUVs will be more expensive to insure than other vehicles, but that doesn’t mean you shouldn’t search for the best possible rate.
If you’re on the hunt for a car insurance policy, try Jerry.
Jerry is a personal insurance broker that lives in your pocket. But don’t worry about buying tiny office furniture, Jerry is an app.
Once you download Jerry, just answer a handful of questions that will take you roughly 45 seconds to complete and you’ll immediately get car insurance quotes for coverage similar to your current plan. Jerry customers save an average of $879 a year. Oh, and we should mention … Jerry is 100% free.
Haven’t shopped for insurance in the last six months? There might be hundreds $$$ in savings waiting for you.
Judith switched to Progressive
Saved $725 annually
Alexander switched to Travelers
Saved $834 annually
Annie switched to Nationwide
Saved $668 annually
Check if you are overpaying for car insurance.
No phone calls. No long forms. Quotes from 45 insurance companies.