Should You Get an Allstate Umbrella Policy?

Allstate’s umbrella insurance policy extends your liability coverage by $1 to $5 million and covers a wider range of damages.
Written by Shannon Fitzgerald
Reviewed by Hillary Kobayashi
background
Allstate’s personal umbrella policy extends your liability coverage if you surpass the limits of your standard
car insurance
or
homeowners insurance
policy. It can also protect the people in your family and household against myriad damages.
If you have a high net worth or own a lot of assets, it may be in your best interest to expand your liability insurance with an umbrella policy. Not only can this coverage save you from maxing out limits and paying significant amounts out of pocket, but it can also cover costs that standard liability doesn’t. 
Is it really worth paying a couple of hundred dollars extra per year? Let’s take a look. 

What is an umbrella insurance policy? 

An umbrella insurance policy, also referred to as a personal umbrella policy (PUP), is a type of insurance safeguard that covers you, your family, and members of your household if you exceed the liability limits of your car insurance or homeowners insurance. 
While umbrella insurance acts as an extension of your
personal liability insurance
, it can also cover you against more damages than your standard policy, too—like slander or defamation lawsuits. 
Most umbrella policies start your
liability coverage
with a $1 million limit and go as high as $5 to $10 million in coverage (
Allstate
only goes as high as $5 million). This is much greater protection than the average $300,000 to $500,000 limit of a standard policy, which can make umbrella insurance a great value—especially since it only costs an average of $150 to $300 a year!
Typically, your standard car insurance or homeowners policy must meet certain minimum liability limits in order for umbrella coverage to be added on. When you file a liability claim, your standard policy’s limits must then be used up first before an umbrella policy kicks in. 
MORE: Home insurance liability coverage
RECOMMENDED
Compare auto insurance policies
No spam or unwanted phone calls · No long forms
Find insurance savings

How does umbrella insurance work with Allstate? 

Allstate
policyholders may purchase a personal umbrella policy if their auto or property insurance has met the following required limits
Insurance type 
Bodily injury
per person
Bodily injury per accident
Auto
$250,000
$500,000
$100,000 per accident or $500,000 combined single limit (CSL)
Motorcycle
$100,000
$300,000
$100,000 per accident or $300,000 CSL
Homeowners
$300,000 per occurrence
$300,000 per occurrence
Additionally, Allstate offers umbrella coverage for motor homes whose liability limits meet the same requirements as those for auto insurance, and RVs and personal watercraft whose limits meet the same requirements as those for motorcycle insurance. 
MORE: What’s the difference between split limit insurance and single limit insurance?

What does Allstate umbrella insurance cover?

Allstate’s personal umbrella policy fills in the gaps of your bodily injury and property damage coverage up to a $1 to $5 million limit and covers certain personal injury losses that standard liability coverage doesn’t. This includes: 
  • Invasion of privacy 
  • Libel 
  • False arrest 
  • Slander, humiliation, or defamation 
Alongside this additional personal injury loss protection, your Allstate PUP also covers defense and attorney costs and expands your liability coverage outside of the country. It can also be extended to cover any relative or dependent in your household. 
Here’s a look at Allstate’s umbrella coverage in action. Let’s say your teenage driver forgets to look when merging on a highway and accidentally causes a three-car collision while picking up groceries for the family. In your state, you are liable for the accident as a parent and are therefore responsible for all of the medical bills and vehicle repairs since your teen was at fault. 
A standard Allstate car insurance policy might only cover up to $500,000 per accident in medical bills and vehicle repairs. But with two full vehicles and seven passengers involved, medical expenses quickly climb up to $580,000. One of the cars is absolutely totaled, and the other one is a severely damaged
Porsche
—so vehicle repairs and replacements swiftly exceed your liability limit, as well. 
Without umbrella coverage, the drivers involved could file personal injury lawsuits against you to collect the damages they’re still owed. In this case, those court costs will come directly out of your pocket since they aren’t covered in a standard liability policy either. 
These costs, along with attorney fees and lost wages while in court, would be covered under a personal umbrella policy, however. 

What it won’t cover

While it may seem that umbrella coverage is as close as you can get to a car insurance catch-all, some losses aren’t covered
In an Allstate PUP, this includes the following: 
  • Business-related liability or damages 
  • Personal belongings 
  • Intentional crimes or omissions 
  • Anything that’s held to an existing written or oral contract 
Here’s an example of how these exclusions can play out. Let’s say you’re hosting a pool party for the neighborhood and a guest slips and falls on your slippery tiles and breaks their back. The medical expenses and lost wages that result exceed the liability limits of your homeowners insurance, but since you have umbrella coverage, you’re still able to handle it. 
Now, here’s a different story. Let’s say instead of hosting a pool party for the neighborhood, you’re hosting a pool-side launch party to promote your latest line of skincare products. Since this is now a business-related expense, it is no longer covered by an umbrella policy—only your business insurance can cover it. 
Compare quotes from 50+ insurers with Jerry in under 45 seconds?
icon4.7/5 rating on the App Store | Trusted by 5+ million customers and 7 million cars
icon4.7/5 app rating | Trusted by 5M+ drivers

How much does Allstate umbrella insurance cost? 

Just like standard insurance coverage, Allstate’s umbrella insurance rates vary based on individual factors like your
driving record
and credit score. However, you can almost always expect it to cost very little, especially for the amount of coverage it gives you. 
In fact, average umbrella insurance policies across the board only cost between $150 and $300 annually—which could come down to just $12.50 a month.

Who can buy a personal umbrella policy from Allstate? 

As long as you have an underlying insurance policy with Allstate that has already reached the required liability limits, you are typically eligible to purchase umbrella coverage. This includes auto, homeowners, renters, and even watercraft insurance. 
That said, not all states offer umbrella coverage, so you’ll want to talk to your Allstate agent to discuss whether a personal umbrella policy is available for you. If it is, you may very well benefit from this extra coverage given the following:
  • You travel (and drive) abroad frequently 
  • You have a swimming pool, swing set, or trampoline at your residence
  • You own (and drive) a boat 
  • You have a
    teen driver
    on your policy 
  • You have a dog 
  • You are at risk of a defamation lawsuit (i.e. someone on your policy is prone to posting negative reviews online or criticizing big names in big ways) 
  • You own a lot of assets that give you a high net worth 

Is an Allstate personal liability umbrella policy worth it? 

While it’s clear that you can receive some very comfortable coverage from Allstate’s personal umbrella policy, is it actually worth it? Here’s a look at some of the pros and cons you may want to consider before buying. 

Pros

It has great value. Adding only $12.50 to $25 to your monthly premiums on average, umbrella coverage is very affordable for the amount of additional protection you receive. 
You get significantly higher limits. A lot of damage can happen with one small mistake, and costs can climb quickly—especially as average car accident costs increase. Umbrella insurance gives you much greater peace of mind that you will be able to recover from an otherwise financial nightmare.
You get broader liability coverage. Not only does Allstate’s umbrella insurance take care of certain legal fees and lawsuits, but it also covers you while you travel both around the country and out of it.

Cons

Your policy as a whole will cost more. Because you need to max out your liability limits before you can secure umbrella coverage, your regular insurance premiums will be higher. This can make umbrella coverage less attainable for many policyholders who don’t already have higher limits.
Umbrella coverage can be limited. Depending on your location and risk profile, you may not always be able to buy Allstate’s personal umbrella coverage for your liability policy. 
Your own injuries and damages are not covered. While Allstate’s PUP covers significant amounts of other vehicles’ damages, your damages aren’t covered by liability insurance. If you’re looking to pad your protection more,
collision insurance
and
comprehensive insurance
are much better options. 

The bottom line

If you’ve already maxed out Allstate’s liability limits in your standard policy, you may strongly benefit from Allstate’s umbrella policy protection—especially if those limits are lower than your net worth
If your current liability limits are still pretty far from Allstate’s maximum values, you may want to build up some coverage first before jumping straight into an umbrella policy. 
“When we added a new car to our family, we were shocked at how high our current insurer was going to hike our rates. We used
Jerry
for some comparison shopping and are now saving around $1000 a year. Thank you, Jerry!” —Darius P.
RECOMMENDED
Jerry automatically checks if you are paying the lowest price for your insurance, for free.
Instantly compare top insurance companies
No spam or unwanted phone calls · No long forms
What insurance do you want to compare?
Are you overpaying for car insurance?
Compare quotes and find out in 45 seconds.
Try Jerry

Easiest way to compare and buy car insurance

√
No long forms
√
No spam or unwanted phone calls
√
Quotes from top insurance companies
Find insurance savings