The Best Car Insurance Companies According to Consumer Reports

Kiana Justice
· 4 min read
Finding the right
car insurance
can often seem like a daunting task. With so many options, it can be hard to pinpoint the policy that fits you best. Luckily, you can turn to some trustworthy online sources for help and guidance.
Consumer Reports (CR) has been breaking down marketplace data for customers everywhere since 1936. You can use their reports to help you decide which car insurance company has what you need. Let’s take a closer look at the CR rankings and the companies that landed in the top three.
USAA is constantly praised for its car insurance | Twenty20

USAA Group

Coming in the prestigious number one spot on
Consumer Reports’ list
was USAA. USAA has a highly respected reputation for working with military members and their families. In terms of their auto insurance coverage, the company is a fan favorite.
These rankings are based on a survey of over 90,000 CR members which asked consumers to rate different experiences with their insurance company. USAA scored top points across the board for consumer satisfaction.
The categories of experiences included things like service,
premium costs
, and handling of claims. On their site, USAA says that on average, drivers save $707 a year when they switch to USAA.
Accident Forgiveness and flexible payment options are a few other perks that are available with USAA's auto insurance policies. Protection and peace of mind are priorities at USAA and testimonies to the company's number one ranking. With an overall satisfaction score of 92, USAA's auto insurance is absolutely worth considering if you qualify for membership.
Let Jerry find your price in only 45 seconds
No spam · No long forms · No fees
Find insurance savings

NJM Insurance Group

Known for a "No Jingles or Mascots" motto, NJM came in second place in CR’s ratings. However, that isn't all NJM is known for. J.D. Power named NJM number one in the nation for outstanding customer satisfaction with auto claims.
In terms of auto insurance, NJM seems to have considered it all. Drivers will be pleasantly surprised to learn that pet coverage, transportation expenses, and new car replacement are just a few other elements included with NJM's policy.
With loads of discounts, specialty coverages, and the ability to personalize and customize policies, it’s no wonder customers gave the company an Overall Score of 90. These are just a few of the many reasons NJM Insurance Group is a good pick.

Amica Mutual Group

Amica has become a trusted leader in the insurance field. This insurance company based in Rhode Island prides itself on providing customers with personalized experiences and offers coverage in just about every possible area of life.
The auto insurance from Amica is definitely worth checking out. Amica understands that cars are more than just vehicles and that no two drivers are the same. With available discounts and stellar customer service, there is a lot to love about Amica.
State Farm
, and Allstate, are just a few of the popular insurance companies Amica beat out in ratings. Amica’s overall score of 89 secured the company a third-place position in the rankings.

How to find a car insurance company that works for you

is a mobile app that’s perfect for this challenge. Just because a company receives a high rating doesn’t mean it’s the best match for you. With that being said, shopping around for car insurance policies from dozens of companies can be a hassle. There are so many options and you want to get the best prices.
Fortunately, Jerry is here to help with that. The free app makes comparing rates easier than ever and more convenient. Use Jerry to put insurance shopping on autopilot, and find the coverage you need at the most affordable price.

Easiest way to compare and buy car insurance

No long forms
No spam or unwanted phone calls
Quotes from top insurance companies
Find insurance savings