Critics and Consumers Disagree Over the Best Midsize Truck of 2021

Aleena Juarez
· 4 min read
Life would be so much simpler if everyone was on the same page. This would be especially true when it comes to buying
car insurance
, or reading reviews when looking for a new vehicle. Sometimes you just want an expert to tell you what options are the best so you don’t have to think about it.
If you’re in the market for a new truck, you might be torn about who to listen to. It seems like the expert critics and other consumers disagree over which 2021 midsize truck is the best. Should you go with the
Colorado or the Honda Ridgeline?
Surveys from J.D. Power seems to show consumers as team Chevy Colorado | Twenty20

Consumers rank the Chevy Colorado number one

J.D. Power
recently released their list of the best small and midsize trucks for 2021. The Chevy Colorado tied with the GMC Canyon in first place. These rankings are based on ratings from verified owners who have typically driven the vehicle for at least a few months.
The owners liked the Colorado’s engine power, overall fuel economy, and the way the vehicle handles. On the flip side, many drivers said the back seats were uncomfortable and that they didn’t have good experiences with the safety systems.
Colorado owners also didn’t like how they couldn’t place personal items exactly where they wanted in the truck.
The starting price for the 2021 Chevy Colorado is $25,200, which makes it one of the most affordable trucks in this category. The one major problem with the Chevy Colorado is that it’s one of the
most expensive trucks to insure
. It's wise to keep this in mind before you go ahead and buy this truck.
Let Jerry find your price in only 45 seconds
No spam · No long forms · No fees
Find insurance savings (100% Free)

Critics rank the Honda Ridgeline number one

U.S. News & World Report's
rankings for the best compact pickup trucks for 2021, the Chevy Colorado only takes third place. The 2021 Honda Ridgeline took the number one spot. U.S. News takes a different approach than J.D. power, and their rankings are based on published reviews from reliable automotive critics.
U.S. News
reported that, "The Honda Ridgeline is a great compact pickup truck with a long list of positive traits that include a muscular engine, a silky ride, tremendous passenger space, and a handsome cabin. It also has one of the highest safety scores in the class."
However, the review also points out flaws with the Ridgeline’s infotainment controls, the high base price, and the subpar towing capacity. With a starting price of $36,490, it's more expensive than most of the trucks in this category.

How do you decide which truck to buy?

Figuring out which truck to buy can be difficult, especially if you're relying on reviews that disagree on which one is the best. You can check out a lot of different review sites but you should probably decide what’s best based on what you value the most.
If you read separate online reviews from drivers, it might give you a better idea of what to expect. Reviews from drivers who have spent a lot of time behind the wheel can probably tell you more about any specific problems they have with a vehicle.
You’ll be more aware of any issues you might have with the truck later on, and it’ll help you decide whether it’s worth purchasing.
If you’re stuck between two great options, it might help to simply head to a local car dealership and test drive each truck. At the end of the day, there will be pros and cons to any vehicle and you’ll have to decide for yourself what works best for you.
Don’t leave insurance as an afterthought. Like with the Colorado, insurance can add significant costs to owning a car. Use
to compare quotes from 45 top insurance companies, and make sure you’re not overpaying for insurance on the car you want.
If you’re
buying a new car
, the free app will also help you switch plans and cancel your old policy for you. It only takes 45 seconds to sign up, and you’ll always know you’re getting the best price on car insurance.

Easiest way to compare and buy car insurance

No long forms
No spam or unwanted phone calls
Quotes from top insurance companies
Find insurance savings — it's 100% free