Tesla Removed Radar for 2 Models Leading to Pulled Safety Ratings

Brandon Moore
· 3 min read
It’s difficult to deny that
is an innovator in the automotive game. But as with any innovator, there are times they'll experience doubters or drawbacks.
Tesla recently removed a key feature from the Model 3 and Model Y, causing a drop in their safety ratings and leaving
car insurance
adjusters scratching their heads. Let's take a closer look at those changes, who pulled their safety ratings, and what else is being said about their
safety features

Tesla was removed from two prominent safety rating lists

Tesla surprisingly pulls a highly-rated safety feature from two model cars | Twenty20
Consumer Reports, the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS), and the National Highway Traffic Safety Association (NHTSA) are three of the leading organizations that rate cars in terms of safety. Their ratings go a long way in the auto industry, building consumer trust.
According to the
Associated Press
, both of those organizations recently pulled their safety rating from two of Tesla's models. Why did they do this, exactly?
It was due to a move Tesla made to its safety systems on their
Model 3 and Y cars
. Tesla removed radar capability from its systems in order to test their new camera-based "Tesla Vision" feature, leading all bodies to pull the ratings.
So what was the damage? For Consumer Reports, they had previously called both models a "Top Pick" in terms of safety.
IIHS had also given the models their highly coveted Top Safety Pick+ rating. And the NHTSA, which had previously given both models marks for having several important safety features, removed them from their website.
Let Jerry find your price in only 45 seconds
No spam · No long forms · No fees
Find insurance savings (100% Free)

Why Tesla wants to be well-rated in terms of safety

NHTSA, IIHS, and Consumer Reports review vehicles' safety features and provide scores to reflect those features. Some of those features they review include:
  • Ability to provide automatic emergency braking
  • Lane departure warning
  • Headlight evaluation
  • Airbag quality
Though this isn’t an exhaustive list, these ratings are helpful to consumers that highly value safety when buying a vehicle.
This is a problem for Tesla because as they look to familiarize the larger car-buying market with their self-driving cars, they'll need all the support they can get. Getting downgraded in terms of safety from highly reputable sources isn't a good look.

What critics have said about Tesla's self-driving systems and safety features

Tesla's drawn plenty of attention for its self-driving cars. While this is certainly an innovation, it hasn't been developed without criticism.
One common gripe is that Teslas lack a laser sensor (also known as lidar). This sensor has an increased ability to see either at night or during inclement weather. Lidar has been a common feature among other companies testing self-driving cars, but it isn't present in Tesla's offerings.
Tesla's "Autopilot" system (given that name by CEO Elon Musk) has struggled with pinpointing other vehicles such as tractor-trailers making a turn in front of its cars.
Three people have died
while in Tesla's Autopilot mode in accidents related to trailers or barriers.
Teslas in Autopilot mode have also hit police vehicles and fire trucks that have their lights flashing. While the NHTSA, IIHS, and Consumer Reports' actions may seem hasty to an outside observer, there's no denying that Tesla has some work to do in order to produce safer vehicles.

Easiest way to compare and buy car insurance

No long forms
No spam or unwanted phone calls
Quotes from top insurance companies
Find insurance savings — it's 100% free