4.7/5 App Store Rating
12,000+ Reviews · Trusted by 3.5M+ Customers

Compare quotes for Toyota Tacoma car insurance cost, 2023

Find out if you're getting ripped off on your car insurance in less than two minutes.
No long forms · No spam · No fees
Jerry partners with more than 50 insurance companies, but our content is independently researched, written, and fact-checked by our team of editors and agents. We aren’t paid for reviews or other content.
The average cost of car insurance for Toyota Tacoma owners is $2,049 a year. However, exact rates vary from model to model: for instance, the Camry Se Night Shade costs $254 more per year to insure than the Pickup 1/2 Ton Short Wheelbase Dlx

Toyota Tacoma car insurance cost

One of the primary determining factors for your Toyota Tacoma insurance rate is the age of your vehicle. Here's how much it costs to insure your Tacoma by car year:
Model year
Average Cost
Annual Savings with Jerry
If you drive a Toyota Tacoma , you can expect your insurance costs to vary depending on trim level, upgrades, and the coverage level you select. Here's how your insurance cost compares to other similar cars:

Best car insurance companies for your Toyota Tacoma

If you drive a Toyota, you probably put a high value on the things Toyota does best: reliability, practicality, and quality that stands the test of time.
Take a look at the table below to see the options different insurance companies offer for Toyota Tacoma drivers.
Insurance company
Average Cost
Annual Savings with Jerry
Aspire Advantage$2,387$1,271
Anchor General
Assurance America$1,842$631
State Auto$1,654$629
National General$1,812$628

Compare car insurance quotes for Toyota Tacoma

But with all the different insurance companies and coverage options out there, how do you find the right insurance? With support from Jerry’s insurance experts, switching policies is close to effortless—with no unwanted phone calls, no duplicate paperwork, and no long wait times.
See for yourself what real Jerry customers saved by shopping for Toyota insurance in the app!
Quote DateZip CodeStateCityNameAgeInsurance Company
Before Jerry
After Jerry
February 1, 202295548CA
Belle L.56Aspire Advantage$5,652$958
January 1, 202223225VARichmondThomas R.31Clearcover$1,308$886
December 6, 202107421NJ
Jon M.30Plymouth Rock$2,880$1,650
May 21, 202177498TXSugar LandGilbert B.73Allstate$1,344$736
February 8, 202033604FLTampaTimothy P.32Bristol West$2,520$1,924

Best car insurance companies for Toyota Tacoma drivers with bad driving records

Look—Jerry knows you’re not a bad driver. In fact, our research shows that nearly 50% of U.S. drivers would rate themselves as “great,” and over half of Americans believe they’re the best driver in their immediate family.
But, well, stuff happens. And when that stuff hits the fan—whether it’s that speeding ticket you got while you were vibing to Beyonce’s new single or the DUI you picked up after that night of bad decisions in college—insurance companies are likely to raise your rates and even label you a “high-risk driver." Take a look at the table below to see how Jerry customers with previous infractions adjusted their rates
Driving Violation
Average Cost
Annual Savings with Jerry
Clean Record$2,205$688
Improper Passing$2,398$1,035
Speeding under 15$1,702$731
Careless Driving$2,624$664
Failure to Obey Traffic Sign$1,308$94

How much does Toyota Tacoma insurance go up after a DUI?

If you get a DUI while driving your Tacoma, you can expect your premium to increase by an average of 26%.

How much does Toyota Tacoma insurance go up after a speeding ticket?

We’ve all been there. If you get a speeding ticket in your Tacoma, your insurance premium could increase by an average of 36%

Best Car Insurance for Toyota Tacoma by Age

If you’re a young driver, you might feel like you need literal superpowers to find decent car insurance at a fair price. That’s because most insurance companies label drivers under age 25 as “high-risk drivers”—regardless of their actual driving record!
The logic makes sense: because young drivers are less experienced, they tend to have statistically higher accident rates. Companies hike young drivers’ premiums to account for their perceived risk, even if their records are spotless.
If you’re under 25, you could be paying as much as $12 more every month for your insurance. Below is a comparison of average rates Jerry customers saw, broken down by age.

Best Car Insurance for Toyota Tacoma by Location

Maybe you’ve got a perfect driving record and you’ve got a decent number of years behind the wheel. But your insurance premiums are still high—why?
It’s all about risk. If you live somewhere with high rates of auto theft, traffic accidents, or severe weather, the risk to your vehicle goes up. Where you see your neighborhood, your insurance company sees a higher chance of expensive claims, and they’ll factor that into your premium.
So where can Toyota Tacoma drivers find the lowest rates—and where can you expect higher-than-average premiums? Take a look at the breakdown below.
Quote DateCar
Before Jerry
After Jerry
Zip codeStateNameAgeInsurance Company
May 21, 2021Toyota Tacoma$112/mo.$61/mo.77498TXJoseph M.73Allstate
January 1, 2022Toyota Tacoma$109/mo.$74/mo.23225VAFrancis I.31Clearcover
February 1, 2022Toyota Tacoma$471/mo.$80/mo.95548CAMatilda W.56Aspire Advantage
December 6, 2021Toyota Tacoma$240/mo.$138/mo.07421NJDavid B.30Plymouth Rock
February 8, 2020Toyota Tacoma$210/mo.$160/mo.33604FLMitchell C.32Bristol West

Driving a Toyota Tacoma

If you own a Toyota Tacoma , here’s what you need to know about your vehicle:
  • The trim level you pick at the dealership affects your insurance rate. Opting for that top-of-the-line TRD trim will cost more upfront, and it’ll add to your monthly expenses.
  • Regular maintenance will keep your [model] in peak shape and help you avoid accidents that could raise your rate. Be sure to follow the recommended maintenance schedule in your owner’s manual!
  • If you bought your Toyota Tacoma new, it’s worth considering new car replacement insurance to protect your investment.
Key Takeaway: The more your Toyota Tacoma is worth, the more you’ll pay to insure and drive it.

How can you save money on insurance for a Toyota Tacoma?

The average annual cost to insure a model is $2,049. But who says you have to be average? Here are a few hacks to help you save money on insurance.

Compare rates

You’ve heard it before: compare, compare, compare. When it comes to finding car insurance savings, comparison shopping is the name of the game.
Here’s why it works: every insurance company uses a different algorithm to set your rate. Unless you have the ability to automatically detect the optimal algorithm for your vehicle, age, zip code, etc., the only way to find the right coverage at the best rate is to compare quotes.
Actually, there is one other way—download the Jerry app, and let Jerry handle the algorithms (and the savings!) By answering a few simple questions, you can get instant access to Jerry’s pool of over 55 top insurance companies, and you’ll see rate comparisons in as little as 45 seconds!

Drive well to save

That’s right, safe driving could literally put money back in your pocket. Not only will tickets send your rate skyrocketing, but you’ll set yourself up for discounts if you can maintain a totally clean record.
If you’re close to that perfect clean record, try out a telematics program like Jerry’s Drive Well, Earn Perks to earn instant savings for your good on-road behavior. And if you’ve already got a driving history that’s, well, less than stellar, don’t despair: Jerry can still help you find low rates and improve your driving (and it’s all on your phone!).

Easiest way to compare and buy car insurance

No long forms
No spam or unwanted phone calls
Quotes from top insurance companies
Find insurance savings — it's 100% free