Top Safety Expert Says There Is ‘No Evidence’ That Partial Automation Makes Cars Safer

President of the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety David Harkey argues that there is no evidence automation makes cars safer.
Written by Allison Stone
Reviewed by Kathleen Flear
background
A person kneeling next to a car with a clipboard doing a safety inspection.
Much like many modern automotive innovations, the intended goal of partial automation is to
make cars safer
—but does it really work? According to top safety expert David Harkey at the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety(IIHS), the evidence is inconclusive.
“Partial automation systems may make long drives seem like less of a burden, but there is no evidence that they make driving safer. In fact, the opposite may be the case if systems lack adequate safeguards,” said Harkey as reported by
KBB
So yes, while increased ease of driving seems to be a net positive, experts like Harkey imply that without proper safeguards, these automated features could actually lead to more instances of distracted driving. 

Are self-driving cars the future?

From automated braking systems when your vehicle detects a pedestrian or obstacle, to lane-centering systems that keep your car from swerving too far out, it seems that the final frontier in automation is the fully self-driving car. 
While automobile manufacturers appear to be in a race to make self-driving cars mainstream, the IIHS cautions against this trend. 
Some manufacturers have oversold the capabilities of their systems, prompting drivers to treat the systems as if they can drive the car on their own,” said the IIHS. 
MORE: Did You Know? Rearview Cameras Have Been Around Since the '50s
Let Jerry find your price in only 45 seconds
No spam · No long forms · No fees
Find insurance savings

A ranking system for automated features

One of the drawbacks to such rapid technological advancement is that it can be hard to implement safety rankings and regulations at the same clip as these systems are being produced. Nationwide, government-implemented safety rankings are also often delayed by the trappings of bureaucracy and public input. 
As an insurance-industry-funded safety agency, the IIHS has an impetus to make automobile accidents as uncommon as possible and can do so without tedious outside oversight. 
That's why the IIHS announced that they themselves will be launching a new safety rankings system, specifically designed to evaluate the safety of automated features
The safety rankings will not test the features of the automated system itself, but rather the adequacy of warnings given to the driver should their eyes, hands, and attention drift from the task of driving.

The car insurance experts at Jerry know safety

Car insurance
costs are largely calculated on risk, and the safer drivers can be, the more money that they can save on car insurance. While getting a car with the newest, most advanced automation features may be exciting for tech and automotive enthusiasts, it's always important to cross-reference these features with recommendations from trusted safety experts. 
As car safety rankings are ever-evolving, your insurance premiums and policies will evolve with them. To ensure you always have the lowest rate, car insurance and broker app
Jerry
will send you new quotes every time your policy comes up for renewal, so you’re always getting the coverage you want at the best price.
Are you overpaying for car insurance?
Compare quotes and find out in 45 seconds.
Try Jerry

Easiest way to compare and buy car insurance

√
No long forms
√
No spam or unwanted phone calls
√
Quotes from top insurance companies
Find insurance savings