WHY YOU CAN TRUST JERRY
Jerry partners with more than 50 insurance companies, but our content is independently researched, written, and fact-checked by our team of editors and agents. We aren’t paid for reviews or other content.
By Shannon Martin
Updated on Jul 5, 2022
Reviewed by Melanie Reiff, Staff Editor.
There are several reasons a tenant may want to break their current lease. While finding a new job in a different location or finally saving up enough money to buy your own home may seem like a reasonable justification, often, it isn't. In New York, there are only a few legal reasons to break a lease, and if you are a renter, it is crucial to know what they are.
Lease and rental agreements are so common that we tend to forget what they really are—legally binding financial contracts that can have heavy penalties if broken. Most lease agreements will stipulate how a landlord will allow you to break a rental agreement without paying fines.
What happens if this isn't the case for you, though? Luckily, Jerry, the super app for saving money on car, renters, and home insurance, is here to help you learn what to do if you need to break your lease and what options you have in New York.
Are you overpaying for car insurance?
When is breaking a lease legal in New York?
In New York, there are five legal ways to break a lease where you can not be penalized:
- Active Duty Military: Service members who are relocated or deployed have protection from The Service members Civil Relief Act(SCRA).
- Unit is uninhabitable: If the landlord doesn't keep the unit in a condition that meets the health and safety guidelines required by New York, the tenant can break the lease and move.
- Privacy violation or landlord harassment: Landlords must be respectful of the tenant's privacy and can not invade the space or harass tenants. Tenant harassment can include failing to maintain the property, threatening to contact immigration, physical and verbal intimidation, or entering the property without just cause.
- Domestic violence: If a tenant is a victim of domestic violence, they can terminate their lease with court approval. The tenant will need to send the landlord a written notification along with documentation like an order of protection and a record of the incident from a health care provider.
- Senior citizen or health issues: Tenants over the age of 62 who can no longer care for themselves and need to move in with family members or a care facility can be released from their lease without a penalty. The same would apply to people with health issues that can no longer care for themselves.
Experienced landlords know that their tenants will need to move at some point. Read your lease carefully, as most landlords include an early termination clause that outlines a notification timeframe that the tenant must give the landlord and how many months of rent will be due if the lease is broken. Some may just need 30 days' notice, while others may require the lease to be paid in full regardless of how much notice is given.
What are the penalties for breaking a lease in New York?
If you want to move in the middle of your lease and have a good relationship with your landlord, the best course of action is to speak with them directly. Offer to help them find a new tenant who meets their requirements. More times than not, this can solve the problem.
This won't work with some landlords, especially if you rent from a corporation instead of an individual. If you have no choice and your situation demands that you must break your lease in New York, you may face some potential consequences:
- You may be required to pay a fine that equals anywhere from one month's rent up to the remaining amount due on your lease term
- May may lose your security deposit regardless of the condition of the unit
- You can get sued for breaking the lease
- While New York landlords can not use credit as a leasing qualification when you are looking for new housing, if your prior landlord has sent your past due rent to a credit collection agency, it will lower your credit score
- Landlords in New York can not use prior rental history like breaking leases and evictions in determining your qualifications for a new apartment, but this information will still show up on your rental history, which can make finding new housing more difficult
- You won't be able to use your landlord as a reference for a future apartment.
Compare insurance quotes from 50+ carriers with Jerry in under 45 seconds
How to break a lease without a penalty in New York
One of the benefits of having a month-to-month lease in New York is that you can move at almost any time without having to worry about a penalty. The requirement for both New York state and New York City month-to-month tenants is to give your landlord at least a 30 days' written notice before moving.
While situations like buying a house, moving in with a partner, or relocating are understandable, they are not legally protected reasons to break a lease. Aside from the reasons listed in the prior section of this article, there aren't any other ways to break a lease in New York without a penalty unless your landlord simply chooses not to pursue legal action. Having a good relationship with your landlord is your best bet to avoid hefty fines and legal troubles. Here are some tips that may help:
- Check your lease: Your lease should be very specific regarding how you can break it and what the penalties are. At least this way, you will know right away what you are responsible for.
- Give your landlord notice as early as possible: The sooner the landlord can find your replacement, the sooner you can leave and not have to worry about fees or possibly paying double rent.
- Sublet (if you're allowed to): Some leases allow for subletting while some strictly forbid it. If you are allowed to sublet or your lease doesn't mention it, check with your landlord and start looking for your replacement.
- Negotiate: If you rent from a small landlord, one that owns just one or two properties, the odds are they can't afford you to up and move out of the blue. Talk with them, see if you can negotiate a partial payment, or maybe show them how a new tenant can afford to pay more than what you do currently.
No matter the reason, early communication and empathy will go far in helping you avoid lease termination fees. Keep in mind that plenty of landlords will fine you and make moving out difficult no matter what you do.
How to save on renters insurance in New York
Moving is usually expensive, and even more so in New York! It all adds up from having to potentially break your lease, paying the security deposit and downpayment for your new place, plus the moving truck.
Luckily, renters insurance is affordable when Jerry, the super app, helps you out. Jerry is known for saving folks money with car insurance, but now we can save you even more with homeowners insurance, renters insurance, or an insurance bundle!
After downloading the Jerry app, getting started takes just 45 seconds, and Jerry customers save on average $800+ per year on insurance!
“Jerry was absolutely worth it. I saved $150, which might not sound like a lot, but really helps me as a New York City resident.” —Jameson T.
Thousands of customers saved on average $887/year on their car insurance with Jerry
This app is great, but the customer service is even better! Not to mention convenient! My husband and I got the lowest rate (much lower than the rates I was finding online through my own searches), quickly, and pretty much all through text message! Thank you so much for a hassle free experience👍
Can I break my lease due to COVID in New York?
New York had one of the most generous eviction moratoriums in the country, allowing tenants to say in their homes even if they could not pay rent. However, the state lifted this moratorium on January 22, 2022. If you want to learn more about the New York moratorium or still need help due to the financial impact COVID-19 has had on your housing situation, click here.
Does breaking a lease affect your credit?
Yes, it can. If your landlord chooses to do so, they can have past due rent and fees sent to collections. Once an account is in collections, your credit score is impacted negatively. Click here to learn more about New York's Fair Consumer Judgment Interest Act for information on timeframes and interest regarding consumer debt.