Reddit Users Pointed Out All the Car Critic Complaints That Don't Make Sense

Brandon Moore
· 4 min read
buying a car
, people choose a particular vehicle for vastly different reasons. Families need reliable cars with room for car seats and groceries. People with a long daily commute might look for great gas mileage. Car lovers who drive for pleasure might be interested in fast sports cars with great handling.
With that in mind, it's hard to review a car in a way that's relatable to all potential drivers. Car critics do their best, and their reviews can be helpful, but Reddit users have highlighted some examples of
car critic complaints
that just don't make sense to them.
The perspective of these Redditors is a good reminder that the most important factor in car buying is your own needs, not the latest luxury add-on or most powerful engine.

Most confusing car critic complaints

Car critics can be a little over-critical sometimes.
this recent thread
, Redditors discuss the car critic complaints that confuse them the most. One recurring example is that critics will often fault an affordable car for lacking higher-end features.
As the Reddit users rightfully point out, affordable cars cost less for a reason, and most car buyers don't expect them to have more luxury features like ventilated seats or fancier interior materials. Sometimes, car critics will fault a car for minor details like interior materials, or even color options, when many car buyers are focused on bigger issues.
Another point of contention is that car critics often prioritize power and handling over features that everyday drivers might care more about, like storage capacity, gas mileage, and reliability.
Many comments on the thread point out that someone shopping for hybrid cars likely cares much more about fuel economy than engine power, and families looking for an SUV are concerned with how their car seats will fit, not the intricacies of the drivetrain.
Let Jerry find your price in only 45 seconds
No spam · No long forms · No fees
Find insurance savings

Why car critics sometimes miss the mark

MORE: Poor Reviews Haven't Hurt Sales of the 2021 Ford Explorer
On the Reddit thread, users put forth a few theories as to why car critics make complaints that aren't necessarily relevant or helpful. According to some Redditors, many car critics are amateurs and may not actually know that much about cars.
As user BigCountry76 points out, reviewers may critique small details of the interior because they "need something to criticize about a car". Some commenters think that car reviewers make these kinds of complaints because they need to fill time in their reviews.
Another point made in the thread is that car critics can't appeal to everyone in their reviews. Some people care a lot about mechanical details, while that same information would bore many car buyers.

Should you ignore car critics?

MORE: What Are Some Good Questions to Ask a Seller Before Buying a Car?
Despite the valid points made in the Reddit thread, you can still learn about a car you're interested in by reading reviews and watching test drive videos. But it makes sense to take a few extra steps to get a more comprehensive view of the car.
Try to find reviews by people in your driver category, not just "car guys." Look for parents reviewing family cars, outdoor enthusiasts testing SUVs, or mechanics discussing a vehicle's reliability.
You can also use sites like
J.D. Power
to find more neutral reviews and car specs. Then, test drive the car yourself before buying. No review can give you the same perspective as getting behind the wheel yourself.
After finding the car that's right for you (whether or not you pay attention to car critics), make sure you also have the right
car insurance
makes it easy to find the right coverage for your needs at an affordable price.

Easiest way to compare and buy car insurance

No long forms
No spam or unwanted phone calls
Quotes from top insurance companies
Find insurance savings