Car Insurance in South Carolina by City

Written by Kevin Berry and 1 other
Updated Jan 31, 2025

Compare quotes from multiple insurers to find the best rate in South Carolina.

Depositphotos 73579059 XL scaled
You’re minutes away from insurance savings.

Location is a major factor that helps determine your car insurance costs. A driver in an inland South Carolina city like Greenville may not pay the same rate as someone living in Myrtle Beach.

But your city is just one piece of the premium puzzle. Your age, driving record, credit, vehicle and desired coverage also impact your costs. Because no two insurers calculate car insurance rates the same way, it’s wise for drivers in all cities to get quotes from multiple providers to find the best deal.

These are the average monthly car insurance quotes that drivers across South Carolina have received via Jerry. Find your city, or one nearby, to see what you could expect to pay — and carry that information with you as you shop for car insurance.

SIMPLIFY YOUR SOUTH CAROLINA CAR INSURANCE IN MINUTES

Car insurance in Aiken, SC

Around Aiken, South Carolina, Jerry customers have often found low car insurance rates with companies like The General, Progressive and Safeco.

Insurance Company
Avg Monthly Quote
The General $206
Progressive $227
Safeco $263
Dairyland $307
National General $312
Last Updated Mar 5, 2025

Car insurance in Anderson, SC

In the Anderson area, insurance companies like Progressive, Safeco and The General have generally provided affordable rates to Jerry customers.

Insurance Company
Avg Monthly Quote
Safeco $134
Progressive $199
The General $232
National General $245
Assurance America $272
Last Updated Mar 6, 2025

Car insurance in Conway, SC

If you’re in the Conway area, you may get a quote for insurance at a rate below the state average from insurers like Progressive, Safeco and The General.

Insurance Company
Avg Monthly Quote
Progressive $241
Safeco $265
The General $265
National General $318
Dairyland $334
Last Updated Mar 5, 2025
SIMPLIFY YOUR CAR INSURANCE IN MINUTES

Car insurance in Florence, SC

Residents of the Florence area can often get competitive rates from big name insurers like The General, Progressive and Safeco.

Insurance Company
Avg Monthly Quote
The General $253
Progressive $265
Safeco $289
Assurance America $317
National General $335
Last Updated Mar 5, 2025

Car insurance in Greenville, SC

Check out insurers like Safeco, Progressive and The General if you’re based in the Greenville area.

Insurance Company
Avg Monthly Quote
Progressive $203
The General $219
Safeco $255
National General $270
Dairyland $324
Last Updated Mar 5, 2025

Car insurance in Greenwood, SC

If you need affordable car insource in Greenwood, look to well-known companies like Progressive, The General and Assurance America. These insurers may quote prices below the state average for drivers with clean records.

Insurance Company
Avg Monthly Quote
Safeco $104
Progressive $167
The General $185
Assurance America $228
National General $238
Last Updated Mar 6, 2025
SIMPLIFY YOUR CAR INSURANCE IN MINUTES

Car insurance in Lexington, SC

In Lexington, Jerry customers have often found low rates with companies like Progressive, Safeco and The General.

Insurance Company
Avg Monthly Quote
Progressive $221
Safeco $251
The General $252
Dairyland $277
Assurance America $282
Last Updated Mar 5, 2025

Car insurance in Myrtle Beach, SC

Companies like Embark, Progressive and Safeco have quoted rates below the state average to Jerry customers in Myrtle Beach.

Insurance Company
Avg Monthly Quote
Safeco $202
Progressive $203
National General $298
Dairyland $320
Assurance America $323
Last Updated Mar 5, 2025

Car insurance in Rock Hill, SC

You may find affordable car insurance options in Rock Hill with companies like The General, Safeco and Progressive.

Insurance Company
Avg Monthly Quote
Safeco $216
Progressive $219
The General $264
Assurance America $338
National General $354
Last Updated Mar 5, 2025
SIMPLIFY YOUR CAR INSURANCE IN MINUTES

Car insurance in Spartanburg, SC

Compared to the South Carolina state average, you can usually get low-cost car insurance in Spartanburg from companies like Progressive, The General or Safeco.

Insurance Company
Avg Monthly Quote
Progressive $216
Safeco $224
The General $246
National General $295
Assurance America $303
Last Updated Mar 5, 2025

Car insurance in Summerville, SC

Look to insurers like Progressive, The General and National General for low-cost coverage in the Summerville area.

Insurance Company
Avg Monthly Quote
Anchor General $107
Progressive $223
Safeco $255
The General $259
National General $352
Last Updated Mar 5, 2025

Car insurance in Sumter, SC

Drivers in the Sumter area may find affordable car insurance from companies such as The General, Progressive and Safeco.

Insurance Company
Avg Monthly Quote
The General $227
Progressive $238
National General $278
Safeco $312
Root $337
Last Updated Mar 6, 2025
SIMPLIFY YOUR CAR INSURANCE IN MINUTES

Methodology

Data for all tables includes quotes in the last 18 months for Jerry customers in the designated city with no violations.