Why would another auto insurance company offer me a lower rate than what I'm currently paying?
I'm with Allstate right now and I requested quotes from other companies. There are a few quotes that are $200 less than what I'm currently paying. Am I being overcharged? Is there something I'm missing?
“Every car insurance company looks at different factors when determining a rate, and they weigh these factors differently as well. These often include your age, driving record, location, and the type of car you drive.
Although you’ve been able to find a lower rate elsewhere, this does not mean that Allstate has been overcharging you.
You may qualify for discounts with other carriers that Allstate doesn’t offer. You could also be a type of insured driver that another company favors, meaning their rates may be more competitive compared to what you’re currently paying.
With such a large price difference, you want to make sure that you’ll be receiving the same amount of coverage if you switch companies. The types of car insurance that companies offer vary, so be sure that the prices you are comparing are for the same coverages. If another carrier’s policy is similar to what you currently have, it may be worth making the switch. “
Did this answer help you?
Ask us a question by email and we will respond within a few days.
Have a different question?
You can meet us at our office and discuss the details of your question.
Read advice from car experts at Jerry
Browse by topics
What others are asking
Do I need my own insurance if I pay a homeowners association fee?
I know part of my homeowners association fee goes toward insurance. Does this mean I'm covered, or do I need to buy my own home insurance?
Mar 08, 2021
Was getting this non owners car insurance policy really a good idea?
I live in Seattle and rent cars frequently. Rather than getting the rental car coverage, I bought a non owners policy with Progressive. It meets all the state liability requirements, but now I have buyer's remorse. Did I get enough coverage?
Apr 29, 2021
Can I return my car to the dealer if I can't pay my loan?
A family emergency came up and I can't pay for my car anymore. Can I return the car to the dealer?
May 05, 2021