Why doesn’t the cost of insurance decrease with the value of my vehicle?
My car is getting older but my insurance is not getting cheaper. Shouldn’t the price be proportionate to the replacement cost of the car?
“While the vehicle’s value is a factor in determining your insurance premium, it is one factor among many and is generally weighted less than other factors, such as driving history and experience.
Even though the collision coverage and comprehensive coverage pay for damages to your vehicle up to the actual cash value of the car—which, as you note, decreases over time—they also pay for the cost of labor to fix your car, which has been increasing over time.
You should use an online broker like Jerry that will re-shop your insurance at every renewal to make sure you are always getting the best price.”
Did this answer help you?
Ask us a question by email and we will respond within a few days.
Have a different question?
You can meet us at our office and discuss the details of your question.
Read advice from car experts at Jerry
Browse by topics
What others are asking
If my car was hit by someone else, will their insurance company pay for the damages if I decide to junk it?
"I drive an old (2006) car and my car was damaged pretty badly when someone hit me at a stop sign. I'm considering junking it and buying a new car, but if I do this, will the other driver's insurance still pay for the damages?"
Jul 27, 2021
If I just bought a pre-damaged Prius, will insurance still cover it?
"I bought this car because it was cheaper, not thinking about the insurance implications. Will I still be able to get a policy?"
Jul 26, 2021
Why did Allstate raise my rate by $400 at renewal?
I live in Los Angeles and switched from Progressive to Allstate six months ago. I just received my renewal offer and my rate has gone up $400. Why did it go up?
Apr 20, 2021