Why did my premium with GEICO increase so much?
After I got into my first wreck, my premium went up by about $1,200. The accident was my fault and I did total my car. Before that, I had been with GEICO for five years and had a safe driver discount in addition to accident forgiveness. Why didn't my accident forgiveness kick in and help spare me this increase? Should I stick with GEICO or try to move to a new company?