What can I do if the at-fault driver will not pay my deductible after a drunken accident?
My drunk neighbor crashed into my car and left a note saying she would pay my deductible. I filed a claim with my insurance and used my collision coverage, but now my neighbor won’t answer the phone or the door. How can I get her to pay up?
“When you file a claim through your insurance company, once they issue a payment on that claim, they have a right to recover the money. Do not attempt to get your neighbor to pay your collision coverage deductible without speaking to your insurance company, as this could interfere with their recovery efforts.
In some cases, the insurance company may allow you to accept a payment from the other party for your deductible only, but you need to speak with them. If it is perceived that you are accepting payments from both the insurance company and the other party, you can get into quite a bit of trouble.
It is best to wait for your insurance company to recover your deductible. If they are unable to recover it, they will let you know. “
Did this answer help you?
Ask us a question by email and we will respond within a few days.
Have a different question?
You can meet us at our office and discuss the details of your question.
Read advice from car experts at Jerry
Browse by topics
What others are asking
"I never got a bill for my car loan. What do I do? "
"I bought a new car online three months ago. Financing was provided by the dealer and supposedly handled through a credit union at three percent interest. The credit union has no record of agreeing to finance the car, and the dealer keeps saying that they’re looking into it. I really like the car and want to pay for it. How should I handle this? "
May 11, 2021
Can you be at fault if you hit a car while trying to avoid another accident?
"I was stopped at a stop light and two other cars almost got into a collision. To avoid it, a car swerved and hit my car. The driver's attorney is saying they aren't at fault because they were avoiding a collision. Is this true?"
Jun 18, 2021
Who are the best providers of car loans?
There are a lot of car loan lenders out there and I don't know who to go with. Who are the best providers?
Mar 08, 2021