Should I rent a car in New York?

I’m taking my family on a vacation in the Empire State. Should we rent a car in New York?

Find out if you’re getting ripped off on your car insurance in less than two minutes.
No spam · No long forms · No fees
Find savings (100% Free)
rating white
3.5k Ratings
Answer provided by
Sarah Gray
Answered on Apr 25, 2022
New York is a beautiful state with a lot of great vacation options for the whole family, but to let you know if you should rent a car in New York, we’d need to know what part of the state you intend to visit.
You should not rent a car if you’ll be spending your vacation in New York City. The NYC metropolitan area is home to some of the worst traffic in the US. Fortunately, NYC is a very walkable city and has a solid public transit system. Save money during your stay by skipping the rental and opting for public transit options instead, like
  • the subway
  • taxi services, and
  • the bus lines.
You should rent a car if you’re going to be exploring the state beyond NYC. Here are some tips for renting a car in New York state:
  • Reserve your car in advance: The fall and spring months are New York’s peak travel season, but reserving your car in advance any time of year will ensure you get the best option at the best price.
  • Determine who can drive the car: If anyone besides you will need to drive the car, be sure their name is included in the rental agreement.
  • Check your rental car insurance: You may have rental car insurance through your current insurance provider or a credit card.
If you don’t have coverage, or you’re not sure it’s the best, let Jerry, the super app for car insurance, help! Just download the app to see how Jerry can help you save on your auto insurance needs.

Here to save on car and home insurance? Great, you do that. We’ll do everything else.

Sign up in under a minute.
No need to fill out forms or shop around. Sign up in 45 seconds to start saving. Jerry does the rest.
Jerry collects and analyzes your current coverage.
Say hello to Jerry, your new insurance agent. We’ll contact your insurance company, review your current plan, then find the coverage that fits your needs and saves you money.
Get the best options before your renewal.
Jerry does all the picky, busy work by comparing prices and coverage from more than 50+ insurance companies. We compare what we find to your current policy and offer you the three best options before every renewal.

Easiest way to compare and buy car insurance

No long forms
No spam or unwanted phone calls
Quotes from top insurance companies
Find insurance savings — it's 100% free