Is car insurance more expensive in NYC than in Los Angeles?

I’m moving from Los Angeles to New York City in a few months, and I’m currently paying a small fortune for my car insurance. Am I finally going to be able to catch a break, or are rates higher in NYC?

Find out if you’re getting ripped off on your car insurance in less than two minutes.
No spam · No long forms · No fees
Find savings (100% Free)
rating white
3.5k Ratings
Answer provided by
Andrea Barrett
Answered on May 23, 2022
We feel you! Insurance rates can get you in cities as big and bustling as New York City and Los Angeles. We hate to disappoint you, but car insurance in New York City is more expensive compared to LA.
Drivers in Los Angeles pay an average of $1,879 a year for car insurance, while New Yorkers pay more than double at an average of $3,914 a year. As if that wasn’t bad enough, the rates in New York City span from $1,378 all the way up to a jaw-dropping $10,464.
While the average car insurance rate in Los Angeles is 34.5% higher than the national average, the average car insurance rate in New York City is a staggering 188.1% higher —and drivers in NYC pay 19.5% more than drivers in other areas of the state.
Why?
With a city as big and busy as NYC, you’re looking at several factors that influence insurance rates, including:
Driving in New York City may not be wallet-friendly—it’s why most people in the city don’t own cars—but if you have to get behind the wheel, you can at least feel confident that you’re getting the best rate on car insurance when you shop with Jerry.
Jerry is the top-rated car insurance app and licensed broker that collects quotes from over 55 top-rated insurers in minutes. Scan your customized quotes, choose the one that’s right for you, and start saving. The average Jerry user saves over $800 a year on car insurance.

Here to save on car and home insurance? Great, you do that. We’ll do everything else.

Sign up in under a minute.
No need to fill out forms or shop around. Sign up in 45 seconds to start saving. Jerry does the rest.
Jerry collects and analyzes your current coverage.
Say hello to Jerry, your new insurance agent. We’ll contact your insurance company, review your current plan, then find the coverage that fits your needs and saves you money.
Get the best options before your renewal.
Jerry does all the picky, busy work by comparing prices and coverage from more than 50+ insurance companies. We compare what we find to your current policy and offer you the three best options before every renewal.