How do I negotiate a car insurance claim?
I was in an accident last week, and am a little worried my insurance won't pay me what I feel I'm owed. How do I negotiate my car insurance claim?
Getting paid what you feel is fair can be a major challenge. Insurance companies lose money when they need to pay out claims, so claim adjusters often try to keep the payout as small as possible.
Before entering negotiations, you’ll also want to have a good understanding of the value of your car and decide on what you feel is fair. In addition to the value of the car, consider the cost to repair your vehicle or any property, emotional stress, medical expenses, and time. It’s a good idea to not take the first number an insurance company offers as they will expect you to negotiate.
Regardless of whether you’re dealing with your provider or the other driver’s insurance company, it’s important to be as organized as possible. After an accident, document everything, from pictures of the accident to any medical bills or mechanic quotes you receive. A paper trail and documentation will help your case when negotiating.
Clearly document all of this in your demand letter. Once you and your insurance company have agreed on a settlement, get the terms in writing so you have proof of what you’re owed.
If you feel like your insurance company is giving you the runaround, use insurance broker Jerry to find a new, better policy. Jerry is an app that gives you personalized quotes in seconds, helping you save time and money. Even better? Jerry takes care of all the paperwork for you, so you have none of the hassles.
Did this answer help you?
Ask us a question by email and we will respond within a few days.
Have a different question?
You can meet us at our office and discuss the details of your question.
Read advice from car experts at Jerry
Browse by topics
What others are asking
How do I negotiate a lower car insurance rate?
I just recieved my new premiums from my insurance provider, and I am NOT happy. How do I negotiate this to a more fair rate?
Oct 27, 2021
How long does it take to insure a car?
I am getting my first-ever vehicle (2020 Volt!), and I'm eager to get on the road. How long will it take to insure my car?
Oct 27, 2021
How do I insure my car outside of my home state?
I have been traveling a lot for work, and will often cross multiple state lines a week. I want to make sure I am protected. How do I insure my car outside my home state?
Oct 27, 2021