After an accident, does the at-fault driver's insurance company have an obligation to rent me the same type of car that I own?

My Camaro got rear-ended and needs repairs. The other driver is at fault and their insurer is providing me with a rental. I want to rent another Camaro, but the insurer won't grant my request. Doesn't the insurer have an obligation to rent me a Camaro since their policyholder is at fault?

Answer provided by
Shannon Martin
Answered on Feb 19, 2021
Shannon is an expert in personal lines liability insurance with 13 + years of insurance industry experience. She also served as a special insurance liaison to AARP members for 6 of those years. She is a graduate of UL Lafayette and currently resides in NY with her family. Shannon is also an amateur juggler, ukulele player, and is a time travel paradox theory enthusiast.
Sorry to hear about your recent accident. The type of rental car the insurance company will provide for you can depend on the guidelines that are filed by an insurance company with the state. The rental car provided in the event of a loss will usually be in the same class or the same size as the insured vehicle.
For example, in the state of New York, a compact car will generally be provided as the rental vehicle. However, if a driver is too tall for a compact car or there are other reasonable exceptions, the insurance company can upgrade the rental. In New Jersey, a driver will be given a rental car of comparable size, but it may not be in the same high-end class as their insured vehicle.
If you’re unhappy with the rental car you are given, it’s best to have a conversation with your adjuster and express any concerns. There may be exceptions or a discounted rate with an upgrade they can help you with.

Did this answer help you?

Ask us a question by email and we will respond within a few days.

Have a different question?

You can meet us at our office and discuss the details of your question.

Easiest way to compare and buy car insurance

No long forms
No spam or unwanted phone calls
Quotes from top insurance companies