An Eagle Dented a Car in Wisconsin: Is It Covered by Car Insurance?

Find out if you’re getting ripped off on your car insurance in less than two minutes.
No long forms · No spam · No fees
Most drivers have at least one interesting story or car repair situation that they’ve been through. Some aren’t quite as entertaining as getting hit by a clown car, but there’s one driver in Wisconsin who might have an even better story.
That’s because it seems his car got dented by an eagle dropping a fish.
eagle flying in the sky
A Wisconsin driver’s car was dented by an eagle dropping a fish.

Something’s fishy in Wisconsin

What would you think if you go to your car, find there’s a huge dent in the hood, and a carp is lying nearby?
Well, if you live in the City of Neenah in Wisconsin, you immediately think an eagle dropped a fish on your hood.
Newsweek reports that a building inspector came out to check the vehicle and discovered this odd scenario. As hilarious as this seems, it wasn’t a minor dent. Most of the hood is dented in, and there’s even a faint impression of the fish.
Everyone agreed that just slapping the hood with a fish couldn’t do that much damage. In order to destroy tt cause that much damage with a carp, it would have to come from up high.
With that in mind, the only viable theory is that an eagle dropped it—unless someone is flying around in a plane and randomly throwing fish out, of course.
While this seems strange, it appears that this happens quite often in Neenah, Wisconsin.

In Wisconsin, it’s raining fish

Life in the City of Neenah certainly isn’t dull. Apparently, there are fish falling from the sky frequently enough that some residents fear being hit in the head with a fish as they walk into work.
In an interview with the Post Crescent, the Neenah office manager Samantha Jefferson said, “I walked into work, and now I have this irrational fear that I’m going to get hit by a fish, but maybe it’s not irrational. It is kind of funny because as it went around City Hall, people were saying that happened at High Cliff last summer, or this just happened to my friend. I think it’s more common than we think.”

Will car insurance cover damage by an eagle?

Considering there’s no real claim for an eagle randomly dropping objects on your vehicle, how exactly do you go about explaining this to your insurance agent? Is there some way to file a car insurance claim?
While it’s not likely you’ll find yourself in this exact scenario—unless you live in the City of Neenah, of course—you may find yourself in a similar situation. One example would be if a tree limb falls on your car. If that’s the case, then comprehensive insurance should cover your claim.
This type of insurance typically covers things like damage due to vandalism, natural disaster, contact with animals or a variety of other unexpected incidents that don’t involve a collision with another vehicle.
While some states require comprehensive insurance, others do not. If you don’t have comprehensive insurance, it might be worth your time to invest in it.
Jerry can help. The free app quotes from up to 45 different insurance companies for you in under a minute, without any long forms to fill out.
Jerry will send you quotes that compare to your current coverage—and as a licensed broker, it can help you with your insurance needs from start to finish. The app also monitors your car insurance rate every six months on an ongoing basis.

Compare Car Insurance for Your Car

Easiest way to compare and buy car insurance

√
No long forms
√
No spam or unwanted phone calls
√
Quotes from top insurance companies
Find insurance savings — it's 100% free

Compare Car Insurance for Your State