Let’s talk about why the Smart Fortwo failed in the U.S. before we get into why the new one would have worked in the U.S.
Smart cars, dumb marketing
Smart cars were originally available in the U.S. beginning in 2008 and sold for nearly a decade before being pulled from the American market in 2019. The Smart Fortwo was a two-seat city car that didn’t quite appeal to the U.S. market and ran counter to the growing trend of ever-larger SUVs and sedans flooding the market.
The publication assumed the reason DaimlerChrysler brought the Smart brand stateside was to address growing concerns over increasing fuel costs; the Smart Fortwo boasted gas mileage figures of 46 mpg city and 69 mpg highway.
Impressive numbers, but not enough to make Americans drop their big, roomy vehicles for something with next to zero cargo space. Especially when a 2006 Toyota Prius managed 11 more miles per gallon.
How is the Smart #1 different?
The rear-wheel-drive Smart #1 weighs over 4,000 pounds and has an estimated range of up to 273 miles (according to European testing standards).
It also marks a transformation of the brand from a super-compact city car maker to something a little more practical (read: larger) for families and commuters.
Will Americans ever drive it?
While the automaker has not announced plans for a North American release—or a reintroduction of the Smart brand to the American market, for that matter—it’s not entirely outside the realm of possibility that the vehicle could eventually end up in the U.S.
But with the increasing popularity of electric vehicles in the states, it could prove profitable for Smart to bring the vehicle to Americans, especially if it’s more appealing than the Fortwo.