Cheapest car insurance in Fort Myers, Florida (Nov 2024)

Written by R.E. Fulton and 2 others
Nov 21, 2024
Insurance price card

Cheapest car insurance in Fort Myers, Florida (Nov 2024)

No long forms No spam or unwanted phone calls Quotes from top insurance companies

You’re minutes away from insurance savings.

How to find the cheapest car insurance in Fort Myers

On average, car insurance in Fort Myers costs about $150 per month for minimum coverage liability insurance, and about $154 per month for full coverage insurance. Fort Myers drivers pay 9% more than the average rate in Florida.

With hundreds of providers and thousands of car insurance products on the market, finding the right coverage—let alone the right price!—can be challenging. Jerry helps you compare quotes and makes finding cheap car insurance in Florida and Fort Myers quick and hassle-free!

Insurance Company
Premium (monthly)
Age
Zip Code
Car
Insurance Coverage
Has Full Coverage
Progressive $323 25 33913 Toyota Yaris Ia State Minimum Yes
National General $228 22 33913 Mercedes Benz Cla 250 No Coverage Yes
National General $131 32 33916 Hyundai Elantra Blue No Coverage No
National General $163 59 33905 Honda Cr-V Lx No Coverage No
Progressive $417 25 33907 Ram 1500 Classic Express State Minimum Yes
Last Updated Nov, 2024

Cheapest Fort Myers car insurance for good drivers

Insurance rates are calculated based on your driving record, age, zip code, past claims, and vehicle type. While the majority of these factors aren’t in your control—you can be a good driver and keep your driving record clean.

Good drivers in Fort Myers can save up to 40% on their insurance, and with Jerry’s DriveShield™, you can track your driving and unlock discounts for safe driving habits. Discover how other drivers are using DriveShield™ to save on their insurance below.

CustomerDriving ScoreInsurance SavingsHas ViolationsInsurance Coverage
Jonas, 259435%No– State Minimum Liability

– Minimum Coverage
Alejandra, 347724%No– 100/30

– Comp/Collision
Jean, 448529%No– State Minimum Liability

– Minimum Coverage
Michelle, 549738%No– State Minimum Liability

– Minimum Coverage
Eric, 646722%No– State Minimum Liability

– Comp/Collision

Best car insurance companies in Fort Myers

Looking for the cheapest car insurance rates in Fort Myers? Jerry conducted the largest insurance shopping survey in the nation to help figure it out.

State Farm is often cited as the cheapest car insurance company in Florida, but some survey respondents reported that they were overcharged and their rates increased frequently. If you’re wondering who to trust among the big five in Fort Myers—GEICO, Progressive, Allstate, USAA, and Liberty Mutual—here’s the truth: the most affordable insurance company is different for everyone.

You’ll need to compare rates from all of them, as well as providers like Assurance America and Safeco, before you can confidently name the best auto insurance provider for you. To get you started, here’s how survey respondents in Fort Myers rated the biggest companies on a scale of 0 to 5.

Insurance CompanyOverall ratingPriceClaims experienceCustomer Service
Liberty Mutual4.64.24.74.5
Progressive4.23.73.64.4
State Farm43.33.74
Geico3.93.13.44
USAA3.92N/A4

How’d we get these scores?
Jerry’s experts conducted one of the largest car insurance surveys in the United States. We surveyed 15,000 policyholders, in all 50 states, over the span of 18 months. These policyholders hold insurance policies with 87 different insurance companies. We surveyed policyholders to gauge their satisfaction with their insurance carriers in: policy cost, customer service, buying and renewal experience, as well as claim experience. These scores were all reported by real customers of the insurance companies.

Best cheap car insurance quotes in Fort Myers

Florida’s minimum car insurance requirements reflect how much insurance you need the carry to legally drive as well as the cheapest coverage option in Fort Myers. However, minimum liability coverage provides minimal financial protection.

You’ll need full coverage if you want to cover the cost of repairing or replacing your own vehicle–but that’s not as easy to get in the Sunshine State as it once was thanks to the current car insurance crisis. Take a listen to what Jerry’s experts have to say about the state of the insurance industry in Florida, and how it could affect your policy choices in Fort Myers.

Cheap minimum liability insurance quotes in Fort Myers

You need both PIP and PDL to drive in Fort Myers because Florida is a no-fault state. Your car insurance policy must include at least $10,000 of PIP coverage and $10,000 of PDL coverage.

If you’re looking to pay the cheapest rates, you can stop reading here. Although sticking with the minimum coverage isn’t advised (more on that later), Jerry has helped many drivers find cheap, no-frills coverage in Fort Myers.

Do you need more than minimum coverage in Fort Myers?

The state’s minimum liability coverage is insufficient for most Fort Myers drivers.

If you cause a serious injury to somebody else in {city}, their medical bills are likely to climb far past $10,000—and because Florida doesn’t require bodily injury liability car insurance, you could be at serious risk of a lawsuit if the other driver’s PIP runs out. The same goes for PDL.

Florida’s car accident laws allow drivers to file personal injury lawsuits up to four years after a crash, so having the right liability insurance is key.

The bottom line: It’s a good idea to consider liability coverage with higher limits for greater financial protection in case of an at-fault accident.

Cheap full coverage car insurance quotes in Fort Myers

Full coverage car insurance is essential for protecting yourself from the costs associated with repairing or replacing your car. It typically includes both collision and comprehensive coverage. Collision insurance pays for damages after an accident, while comprehensive insurance pays for damages after a vandalism, theft, or natural disaster.

Your lender will usually require collision and comprehensive coverage if you finance or lease your car. And even if your vehicle is paid off, you should carry full coverage if its value exceeds $3,000.

Insurance Company
Premium (monthly)
Age
Zip Code
Car
Insurance Coverage
Has Full Coverage
Progressive $323 25 33913 Toyota Yaris Ia State Minimum Yes
National General $228 22 33913 Mercedes Benz Cla 250 No Coverage Yes
Progressive $417 25 33907 Ram 1500 Classic Express State Minimum Yes
National General $219 40 33916 Toyota Rav4 Le No Coverage Yes
Bristol West $170 56 33907 Hyundai Accent Gls No Coverage Yes
Last Updated Nov, 2024

The easiest and fastest way to find the cheapest car insurance for your preferred coverage option is to compare car insurance rates online.

Jerry, a top insurance agency, offers a free app that compares car insurance quotes and provides end-to-end service to customers with the help of 100+ licensed insurance agents.

Average cost of car insurance in Fort Myers

Based on our experience working with thousands of Fort Myers insurance policyholders, minimum liability coverage costs an average of $150 per month or $1,806 per year, while full coverage insurance costs an average of $154 per month or $1,848 per year.

Note that the type of car you drive, your driving record, claim history, and demographics all play a role in how your insurance premiums are calculated. Although the average rates in Fort Myers can give you an idea of the cost, the full price of your policy could vary by hundreds of dollars.

Average cost of car insurance in Fort Myers by zip code

Your zip code tells your car insurance provider where to send your bills, but it also hints at how likely you are to make a claim.

How? Some zip codes are “riskier” than others, either because of a high rate of congestion, crime, or car accidents (or all three). The drivers living in these neighborhoods tend to pay more than people in other parts of Fort Myers.

Zip CodeAverage State Minimum Coverage RateAverage Full Coverage Rate
33901$165$267
33905$144$205
33907$111$222
33908$114$192
33912$71$254
33913$91$296
33916$189$278
33966$121$208
34112$123$241

Car insurance quotes in Fort Myers by rating factors

Is car insurance calculated at random? No, even if it seems like it. Here are the five factors that determine the rates you pay for Fort Myers car insurance:

  • Driving record and claims history: A history of car accidents and traffic tickets may increase your insurance premiums.
  • Vehicle location: Some ZIP codes come with higher rates.
  • Vehicle type: Sports cars, luxury cars, and high-performance cars tend to have higher collision and comprehensive coverage rates.
  • Usage: If you use your car regularly for work, your annual premium may be higher than if you use it only occasionally for pleasure.
  • Credit score: Drivers with good credit typically pay lower insurance premiums than those with bad credit for the same coverage.

Cheap car insurance quotes in Fort Myers after driving violations

Your Florida driving record can significantly affect your car insurance rates. High-risk drivers receive proportionally higher insurance premiums. While a conviction for running a red light, committing a DUI, or reckless driving in Florida makes it harder to find an affordable rate in Fort Myers, it’s not impossible.

Cheapest car insurance in Fort Myers after speeding ticket

Florida speeding tickets come in several different flavors, each with a different amount of driver violation points:

  • 1-5 MPH over limit: No points
  • 6-9 MPH over limit: 3 points
  • 10-14 MPH over limit: 3 points
  • 15-19 MPH over limit: 4 points
  • 20-29 MPH over limit: 4 points
  • 30 MPH or more over limit: 4 points and mandatory court appearance

The more severe the offense, the more you’ll pay for car insurance. In spite of this, Jerry has helped a number of drivers save money by finding the lowest rates in Fort Myers.

Speeding Type
Insurance Company
Premium (monthly)
Age
Zip Code
Car
Insurance Coverage
Has Full Coverage
Speeding Violation-Major Embark General $283 21 33916 Chevrolet Malibu Ls No Coverage No
Speeding Violation-Major Bristol West $275 31 33905 Kia Rio Lx No Coverage No
Speeding Violation-Minor National General $96 28 33907 Honda Accord Touring Hybrid No Coverage No
Speeding 1-5 Infinity $347 48 33905 Mercedes-Benz Cla 250 State Minimum Yes
Speeding Violation-Minor National General $227 33 33905 Chevrolet Impala Limited Ls No Coverage No
Last Updated Nov, 2024

Cheapest car insurance in Fort Myers after DUI

Committing a DUI in Florida can have a significant impact on your car insurance rates. Insurance companies often view DUI offenders as high-risk drivers, which can result in higher premiums.

If you have a DUI on your record, it’s important to shop around and compare rates from multiple insurance companies to find the most affordable option. Jerry can help you find the best rates for auto insurance in Fort Myers even after a DUI conviction.

Cheapest car insurance in Fort Myers after an at-fault accident

Your driving record in Florida is one of the crucial factors that affect your car insurance rates. Insurance companies look at any past accidents where you were at fault to determine the level of risk you pose to your insurer.

If you have been involved in an at-fault accident in the recent past, your car insurance rates in Fort Myers could significantly increase when your policy is up for renewal. It is essential to shop around and compare rates from different insurers to find the cheapest auto insurance after an at-fault accident.

Accident Type
Insurance Company
Premium (monthly)
Age
Zip Code
Car
Insurance Coverage
Has Full Coverage
At Fault With No Injury National General $228 22 33913 Mercedes Benz Cla 250 No Coverage Yes
At Fault With No Injury National General $131 32 33916 Hyundai Elantra Blue No Coverage No
At Fault With No Injury National General $163 59 33905 Honda Cr-V Lx No Coverage No
At Fault With No Injury Progressive $417 25 33907 Ram 1500 Classic Express State Minimum Yes
At Fault With No Injury National General $219 40 33916 Toyota Rav4 Le No Coverage Yes
Last Updated Nov, 2024

Cheapest car insurance in Fort Myers after other driving violations

Apart from speeding tickets and DUIs, there are several other violations that can lead to an increase in car insurance costs in Fort Myers, including careless driving, driving without a license, and reckless driving.

We’ve compiled a list of various other driving violations and how we helped drivers with these violations save on their car insurance.

Violation
Insurance Company
Premium (monthly)
Age
Zip Code
Car
Insurance Coverage
Has Full Coverage
Careless Driving National General $228 22 33913 Mercedes Benz Cla 250 No Coverage Yes
Driving on Sus. License National General $131 32 33916 Hyundai Elantra Blue No Coverage No
Other Minor Progressive $122 32 33907 Chevrolet Malibu Lt State Minimum No
Other Minor Bristol West $697 29 33913 Kia K5 Lxs No Coverage Yes
Failure to Stop National General $147 42 33905 Kia Sportage Ex State Minimum Yes
Last Updated Nov, 2024

Cheap car insurance quotes in Fort Myers by age

Young drivers typically have limited driving experience and are therefore considered high-risk by insurance companies, resulting in high insurance rates. However, when drivers reach the age of 25, they may see a drop in their rates.

On the other hand, drivers over the age of 75 may see an increase in their rates due to potential health issues and slower reflexes.

Cheapest car insurance in Fort Myers for young drivers

In Fort Myers, young drivers between the ages of 16 and 21 pay the highest insurance premiums of any age group.

The best financial protection for young drivers is full-coverage car insurance, which provides coverage for all their mistakes while they learn the rules of the road. The cheapest car insurance for young drivers comes with a provider that offers good student or new driver discounts.

Cheapest car insurance in Fort Myers for senior drivers

Similar to teenage drivers, car insurance rates for senior drivers are typically higher than the national average. Insurers consider senior drivers high-risk because:

  • Senior drivers have a higher likelihood of being involved in car accidents
  • Accidents involving senior drivers typically result in more severe injuries and increased medical expenses

Cheap car insurance quotes in Fort Myers based on insurance history

If you’ve had a car insurance lapse or you’re currently uninsured, it can lead to higher car insurance rates.

To help our customers avoid a lapse in coverage and make payments on time, Jerry sends payment reminders to eligible customers when a payment is due or if they’re late on their payments.

We’ve helped many customers in Fort Myers who are currently uninsured or have had a lapse in coverage find affordable insurance options.

Cheap car insurance quotes in Fort Myers for drivers with poor credit

While your credit rating doesn’t necessarily reflect your driving ability, insurance companies have found a correlation between lower credit scores and higher claim filings. Fort Myers drivers with poor credit scores tend to face higher car insurance costs than those with good credit scores.

If you have a credit score of 550 or less, Jerry partners with companies that provide insurance to Fort Myers drivers with poor credit, taking the stress out of comparison shopping.

Here’s how drivers with low credit scores saved with Jerry.

Credit Range
Insurance Company
Premium (monthly)
Age
Zip Code
Car
Insurance Coverage
Has Full Coverage
550-659 Progressive $323 25 33913 Toyota Yaris Ia State Minimum Yes
550-659 National General $228 22 33913 Mercedes Benz Cla 250 No Coverage Yes
550-659 National General $131 32 33916 Hyundai Elantra Blue No Coverage No
550-659 Progressive $417 25 33907 Ram 1500 Classic Express State Minimum Yes
660-750 National General $219 40 33916 Toyota Rav4 Le No Coverage Yes
Last Updated Nov, 2024

If you want to save on car insurance, avoid sports cars, luxury SUVs, and high-performance models. These vehicles might be beautifully-made, but they cost a ton to repair, and thus insure.


Insurance companies look at a vehicle’s cost of repairs and replacements, likelihood of theft, and safety ratings when determining its insurance premiums. Here are the top five picks of Fort Myers drivers that perform well in all three categories:

  • Toyota Camry
  • Honda Accord
  • Ford F-Series
  • Chevrolet Silverado
  • Nissan Altima
Popular Car
Insurance Company
Premium (monthly)
Age
Zip Code
Insurance Coverage
Has Full Coverage
Nissan Altima 2.5 Gainsco $157 29 33919 No Coverage No
Toyota Camry L Progressive $80 32 33905 State Minimum No
Nissan Altima 2.5 Gainsco $321 25 33916 No Coverage No
Honda Accord Ex National General $135 41 33916 No Coverage No
Honda Accord Touring Hybrid National General $96 28 33907 No Coverage No
Last Updated Nov, 2024

Cheapest car insurance in Fort Myers for new vs. old car

It usually costs more to insure a new car in Fort Myers than an older one. According to our research, the average cost of full coverage insurance for a car over 10 years old is $111 per year. However, the average cost for insuring a car less than 4 years old increases to $134 per year.

How to lower car insurance costs in Fort Myers

1. Shop around and compare quotes

You can’t be 100% certain that you’ve found the best deal on auto insurance until you’ve compared it to the other products on the market. Experts recommend shopping for car insurance quotes from at least three different companies every six months.

Sounds like a huge chore—until you remember that Jerry makes the process lighting-fast! Get signed up in 45 seconds and compare five to seven quotes in less than a minute. It’s all the benefits of comparison shopping with none of the time commitment… and did we mention it’s free?

2. Hunt for car insurance discounts

You can make an okay rate into a great one with the right car insurance discount. See if your provider offers a program for:

  • Good drivers. If you’ve held a clean driving record for at least three years, you’re due for some sweet discounts.
  • Installing a telematics device. Telematics devices track how far you drive, when you drive, and how you drive. If you brake often and hard, this isn’t the program for you. But if you’re a calm and mellow driver, you could reap a low rate as a reward!
  • Good students. Full-time high school and college students with a B average or better can translate their scholastic successes into savings.
  • Bundling insurance products. Bundle your car and home insurance and you could pay less for each of them.

3. Increase your deductible for comprehensive and collision coverage

If you’ve got full coverage car insurance, increasing your deductible is an easy way to keep your monthly expenses low without sacrificing coverage.

FAQ

  • How much is car insurance in Fort Myers?
  • What is the cheapest car insurance in Fort Myers?
  • What is the best car insurance in Fort Myers?
  • What is the minimum car insurance in Fort Myers, Florida?
MEET OUR EXPERTS
meet-experts-thumbnail
R.E. Fulton
  • Licensed Insurance Agent

R.E. Fulton is an expert insurance writer specializing in car ownership topics from car shopping and loan advice to insurance and repair guides. R.E.’s mission is to create unique and accessible content that helps readers to become more successful and independent car owners. R.E. has written and edited over 900 high-performing articles for Jerry, with an average of 1 million+ views. As a senior writer on Jerry’s editorial team, R.E. draws on over 10 years of experience as a professional writer and digital publishing specialist. Prior to joining Jerry’s editorial team in 2021, R.E. worked as a writing coach at Columbia University, the Rochester Institute of Technology (RIT), and the University of Rochester. They serve as a managing editor for peer-reviewed history publication Nursing Clio, where their work has appeared regularly since 2015.

meet-experts-thumbnail
Lina Zhang

Lina Zhang is co-founder and vice president of operations at Jerry, where she leads a global team responsible for operations, talent acquisition, content, legal, and compliance. Lina’s operational excellence was a critical enabler of Jerry’s 10x growth in its first year of operation.

Prior to Jerry, Lina and her Jerry co-founders, Art Agrawal and Musawir Shah, led YourMechanic, the largest on-demand car repair services provider. In one year, Lina built and scaled YourMechanic operations from five markets to more than 50. The trio left YourMechanic to incubate Jerry at Y Combinator in 2017.

Lina’s previous roles include intellectual property attorney at Morrison & Foerster LLP and a biomedical researcher at Stanford University.

Lina holds a bachelor’s degree in biochemistry from Nanjing University, a doctorate in biochemistry from Dartmouth College, and a juris doctorate from the University of California Berkeley School of Law. She’s a member of the State Bar of California and a licensed property and casualty insurance producer in all 50 states.

meet-experts-thumbnail
Josh Damico

As Vice President of Insurance Operations at Jerry, Josh Damico leads teams across product development, operations and carrier relations, integrating Jerry’s smart and fast car insurance customer experience with that of traditional carriers to help customers find savings and coverage. Josh’s nearly 20 years of insurance-industry experience and knowledge generate partnerships with more than 55 name-brand and specialty insurance partners that enable Jerry to serve customers with all types of vehicle and policy needs.

Previously, Josh held executive roles at Geico, where he had vast regional oversight and leadership opportunities. In his most recent role as director of sales, servicing, and underwriting, Josh developed and executed profit and growth strategy for the New England states and New Jersey.

Josh holds a bachelor’s degree in business administration and management from Medaille College.

Methodology

The Insurance Research Team analyzes insurance products and services to drive insights and help consumers make informed purchase decisions.

Insurance research

We analyzed over 25 million car insurance quotes; conducted the largest insurance shopping survey (over 15,000 customers surveyed and 85 carriers reviewed in the past 18 months).

We surveyed insurance policyholders for their experience with their insurers in the following areas: (1) insurance cost (2) customer service (3) insurance buying experience (4) insurance renewal experience (5) claim experience. In addition, we asked people what they like about their insurers and what areas in which their insurers could improve. The driver characteristics used in calculating average rates for auto insurance include: single driver, single car, currently insured, clean driving record.

For the quotes and sold policies included in this article, please note that personal information has been hidden. Not all customers find savings.

Team

The team consists of licensed insurance agents, insurance industry veterans, and data scientists.

For illustrative purposes only, results may vary

Editorial Note: This article was written by a paid member of Jerry’s editorial team. Statements in this article represent the author’s personal opinions and do not constitute advice or recommendations. You should consult with an insurance professional about your specific circumstances and needs before making any insurance decisions.