Car Insurance in Arizona by City

Written by Kevin Berry and 1 other
Updated Feb 3, 2025

Depending on where you live in Arizona, you car insurance rates can vary. Be sure to shop around for a good deal.

Depositphotos 26190117 XL scaled
You’re minutes away from insurance savings.

Your location within a state can be a major factor that helps to determine your car insurance rate. A driver in a dense metro area like Phoenix may not pay the same premium as someone living in Kingman.

However, your location is just one factor that insurers use to calculate your rate. Other factors like your age, driving history, vehicle type and coverage level also impact the cost. Since no two companies calculate insurance costs the same way, it’s smart for drivers in all locations to get quotes from multiple providers to find a good deal.

These are the average monthly car insurance rates that drivers across Arizona have been quoted via Jerry. Find your city, or one nearby, to see what you could expect to pay — and use that information as you shop for car insurance.

SIMPLIFY YOUR ARIZONA CAR INSURANCE IN MINUTES

Car insurance in Bullhead City, AZ

Jerry customers in Bullhead City have received rate quotes that are below the state’s average from companies like Mendota, Aspire and Assurance America.

Insurance Company
Avg Monthly Quote
Aspire Advantage $76
Mendota $93
Assurance America $107
National General $108
Progressive $112
Last Updated Mar 20, 2025

Car insurance in Casa Grande, AZ

If you’re looking for car insurance in the Casa Grande area, Jerry customers have found low rates with insurers like Dairyland, Aspire and National General.

Insurance Company
Avg Monthly Quote
Aspire Advantage $65
Assurance America $123
National General $128
Dairyland $138
Progressive $173
Last Updated Mar 20, 2025

Car insurance in Chandler, AZ

Residents of Chandler can often find low-cost car insurance from big-name companies like Safeco and Progressive.

Insurance Company
Avg Monthly Quote
Aspire Advantage $110
National General $158
Bluefire $177
Progressive $181
Commonwealth Insurance $196
Last Updated Mar 20, 2025
SIMPLIFY YOUR CAR INSURANCE IN MINUTES

Car insurance in Flagstaff, AZ

You should have several options if you’re searching for affordable car insurance in Flagstaff. Jerry customers have received affordable quotes from insurers like Bluefire, Progressive and Aspire.

Insurance Company
Avg Monthly Quote
Aspire Advantage $69
Bluefire $90
Progressive $108
National General $108
Mendota $122
Last Updated Mar 20, 2025

Car insurance in Gilbert, AZ

Drivers in the Gilbert area may have luck with companies like Aspire, Root and National General, which have offered rates to Jerry customers that are below the Arizona state average.

Insurance Company
Avg Monthly Quote
Aspire Advantage $131
National General $161
Progressive $171
Assurance America $196
Commonwealth Insurance $198
Last Updated Mar 20, 2025

Car insurance in Glendale, AZ

Bluefire, Safeco and Progressive often quote drivers in Glendale car insurance rates below the Arizona state average.

Insurance Company
Avg Monthly Quote
Aspire Advantage $125
Safeco $179
National General $213
Progressive $223
Assurance America $228
Last Updated Mar 20, 2025
SIMPLIFY YOUR CAR INSURANCE IN MINUTES

Car insurance in Kingman, AZ

You should find several affordable options for car insurance in Kingman, Arizona, including National General, Mendota and Assurance America.

Insurance Company
Avg Monthly Quote
Mendota $75
Aspire Advantage $77
National General $82
Commonwealth Insurance $90
Bluefire $107
Last Updated Mar 20, 2025

Car insurance in Scottsdale, AZ

Those with clean driving records can usually get good car insurance rates in Scottsdale through companies like Aspire, Bluefire and Progressive.

Insurance Company
Avg Monthly Quote
Aspire Advantage $106
Bluefire $134
Safeco $151
Progressive $162
National General $182
Last Updated Mar 19, 2025

Car insurance in Surprise, AZ

You shouldn’t be surprised by several low-cost car insurance options in Surprise, Arizona. Compare quotes from insurers like Aspire, National General or Safeco which often quote Jerry customers affordable rates.

Insurance Company
Avg Monthly Quote
Aspire Advantage $129
Bluefire $143
National General $161
Trexis $194
Dairyland $202
Last Updated Mar 20, 2025
SIMPLIFY YOUR CAR INSURANCE IN MINUTES

Car insurance in Tempe, AZ

If you’re on the hunt for car insurance in Tempe, consider insurers like Aspire, Safeco or Progressive, which have often quoted affordable rates to Jerry customers.

Insurance Company
Avg Monthly Quote
Aspire Advantage $87
Anchor General $103
Progressive $163
Safeco $174
National General $179
Last Updated Mar 19, 2025

Methodology

Data for all tables includes quotes in the last 18 months for Jerry customers in the designated city with no violations.