Most Car Buyers in January Paid Above the Suggested Retail Price

Americans are certainly familiar with the lasting effects of the coronavirus pandemic. With inventory shortages and sales over MSRP, the car market is no exception.
Written by Kerry Gibson
Reviewed by Kathleen Flear
background
person holding out money by a cutout of a car in front of a green background
Not surprisingly, supply chain issues have been an ongoing struggle since the beginning of the pandemic. For the automotive industry, specifically, this means a lack of computer chips and factory workers. Meanwhile,
car buying
is on the rise, resulting in an economic dilemma of supply not meeting demand.
Vehicle inventory has dramatically reduced, giving dealerships the advantage of hiking their prices. Is the current state of the market sustainable over the long run? Experts are divided on their predictions for the future of car buying.

Car buying has never been pricier

January 2022 saw 80% of car buyers paying above the manufacturer’s suggested retail price (MSRP), as reported by
CNN
. This is shocking news after a long period of price reduction offers from dealerships. For context, only 2% of buyers paid above MSRP just a year ago.
The average transaction price on new vehicles is up 15% from January 2021, at $45,717. One significant reason for the difference is the popularity of SUV and pickup truck models, especially those with expensive safety features. These vehicles tend to be more costly than sedans, which currently are less in demand.
However, dealers are no longer incentivized to offer deals when vehicles are only on the lot for an average of 10 days. If a buyer walks away, there will be another one right behind them who’s willing to pay above the sticker price.
Car buying is even more challenging in the used sector. Prices are soaring even higher than we’ve seen with new cars, all due to inventory shortages. Trade-in values increased by $8,000 over 2021, but options are diminished.
Let Jerry find your price in only 45 seconds
No spam · No long forms · No fees
Find insurance savings

Automakers weigh in

Dealerships are the sole beneficiaries of these growing profit margins, since they buy their inventory from the automakers at a wholesale cost. Of course, customers are not pleased with the idea of paying more than the MSRP.
AutoNation’s CEO has a differing opinion. He believes that significant discounting is actually quite harmful to brands and that car buying should be reflective of the suggested pricing.
Meanwhile, Ford and General Motors have both come to the aid of concerned customers. Dealers have received letters warning against abusive practices that may result in a reduced allocation of new vehicles. Some customers with deposits on upcoming EV models have been told they need to pay thousands above the price they expected to pay. The exact limitations on pricing, however, remain unclear.

The future of car buying

MORE: How to Estimate Trade-In Value For Your Car
According to
NBC
, analysts do not expect the situation to change before 2023. It’s in the best interest of dealers and automakers to keep inventory low, so as not to exceed car buying demand.
There were 17.1 million new vehicles sold in the U.S. in 2019. That number dropped to 14.9 million in 2021.
Other experts expect new car discounts to return post-pandemic, as buyers without a trade-in won’t be willing to pay more than the sticker price.
If recent car buying has blown your budget,
Jerry
can help you save money on your car insurance. Download the Jerry app, answer a handful of questions and receive quotes from over 50 top insurance carriers. Find the best coverage at the best price with Jerry!
Are you overpaying for car insurance?
Compare quotes and find out in 45 seconds.
Try Jerry

Easiest way to compare and buy car insurance

√
No long forms
√
No spam or unwanted phone calls
√
Quotes from top insurance companies
Find insurance savings