2 Midsize SUVs That Hit Consumer Reports Used Car ‘Sweet Spot'

Consumer Reports found two cars that they think hit the used car ‘sweet spot’. We’ll tell you what they are, but first, what criteria did they meet to win this praise?
Written by Hannah DeWitt
Reviewed by Kathleen Flear
background
When it comes to purchasing a vehicle, sometimes it's best to go for a
used car
. It is possible to find something reliable, especially if you know
what to look for
. However, two midsize SUVs sit at the top of the list regarding reliability.

Three is the magic number in terms of car age

According to an article on reliable used cars by
Consumer Reports
, you should aim to purchase a used car that is three years old. Most three-year-old cars still have low mileage, though how the car was treated throughout its miles is important. In addition, leases on cars last for three years, and the lessor would have to keep the car in good condition for that entire period.
Also, most cars receive an upgrade in features every four to five years, if not less. As a result, there is rarely a large gap in time between the generations of car models in the modern era. That means that there's a big chance a three-year-old car will have many of the same features as a brand new car.
So, if you're looking to purchase a used midsize SUV that goes back three years, which one hits that sweet spot of reliability? It turns out it's a tie between the 2019 Nissan Murano and the 2019 Toyota 4Runner.
Let Jerry find your price in only 45 seconds
No spam · No long forms · No fees
Find insurance savings

The 2019 Nissan Murano carries over many features from the SUV that came before it

Nissan is no stranger to innovative technology. And, when they find something that works, they know how to upgrade it without fundamentally altering its form or function. That's how Nissan maintained the sporty styling and comfort in the 2019 Murano.
The interior of the Murano includes impressively comfortable seating in both the front and rear of the vehicle. The rear seating is exceptionally spacious, giving passengers more than enough room. Standard technology options include Apple CarPlay and Android Auto for smartphone connectivity and several USB and USB-C ports. 
Looking under the hood, you'll see that the Murano carries over quite a bit from its predecessor. A 3.5-liter V6 engine provides 260 horsepower with 240 pound-feet of torque. Pairing this engine with a variable automatic transmission gives the Murano a responsive ride with adequate acceleration and speed.
The current price range for a used Murano sits at $25,388 - $41,998.

How does the 2019 Toyota 4Runner stack up as a midsize SUV?

When it comes to iconic SUVs, it can be challenging to look past the Toyota 4Runner. The 2019 model is the ninth generation of Nissan's flagship SUV. Yet, despite Toyota making a considerable commitment to innovation, it comes with very few changes to its design or function overall.
The 4Runner's design is built on a truck-based platform rather than a car-based platform. This choice makes it great for off-road adventures. However, it doesn't fare as well on the pavement in terms of handling.
Standard interior options include cloth upholstery, a leather-wrapped steering wheel, and an eight-way adjustable driver's seat. The 4Runner features a 6.1-inch touch-screen multimedia center, Bluetooth connectivity, streaming audio, and satellite radio. Navigation and an upgraded stereo are optional, but the 4Runner does not support Apple CarPlay or Android Auto.
A 4.0-liter V6 engine gives you 270 horsepower with a standard rear-wheel drivetrain and the option of four-wheel drive. The engine comes standard with a five-speed automatic transmission that provides smooth and precise shifts, though its truck frame gives it a stiffer suspension, meaning you'll feel most bumps in the road.
The average price range for a used 2019 4Runner sits at $40,576 - $54,711. Considering the higher price tag for fewer features, it's hard to see how the Toyota 4Runner could beat the Nissan Murano in terms of value.
MORE: Other Midsize Trucks Simply Can't Keep Up With the Toyota Tacoma

Find insurance that also hits the sweet spot

Whether you choose to drive off in a Toyota 4Runner, a Nissan Murano, or any other SUV, you need affordable insurance. And for that,
Jerry
has you covered. We save drivers an average of $887 a year on insurance by comparing quotes from top companies.
Are you overpaying for car insurance?
Compare quotes and find out in 45 seconds.
Try Jerry

Easiest way to compare and buy car insurance

√
No long forms
√
No spam or unwanted phone calls
√
Quotes from top insurance companies
Find insurance savings